Skip to content Skip to sidebar Skip to footer

Elouise Massa said staff showed ‘no urgency’ before son’s death

Joe Massa’s mother has told an inquest she repeatedly raised concerns about her son’s worsening condition in the hours before he suffered a cardiac arrest

The mother of a two-year-old boy who died after being taken to a Sydney hospital says the rapid decline of her son’s health was met with “no urgency” by hospital staff in the hours before he went into cardiac arrest.

The coronial inquest into the death of Joe Massa has begun with a forensic recount of the final 24 hours of his life, during which the “happy and healthy” young boy’s condition rapidly deteriorated before his death just before 9pm on September 16, 2024.

While being questioned by counsel assisting Donna Ward SC, Joe’s mother Elouise Masa said a doctor tasked with overseeing the response to her son’s deteriorating condition “looked out of his depth” as hospital staff tried to figure out what was wrong with the little boy.

“He did not look concerned. He looked out of his depth. He was standing back, and others were looking at him … [there was] no urgency,” she said.

“I was saying there’s a rash [on Joe’s body], and he was standing back now at this point with his arms folded. I recalled him looking relaxed, that’s what I perceived. It was becoming quite a hyped-up area and I kept looking at him saying ‘can’t you see he’s so unwell?’.”

Ms Massa said Joe was “declining rapidly” and “not himself” at the time of the exchange.

Earlier, before Joe was taken to hospital, Ms Massa said her son looked “terrible”.

“He could barely keep his head up. He was floppy, his hands and feet were cold to touch. He was open mouth breathing, even at that stage,” she said.

In painstaking detail, Ms Ward walked presiding judge State Coroner Her Honour Judge Teresa O’Sullivan through Joe’s final hours, including the devastating 30 minutes in which Northern Beaches Hospital staff desperately tried to revive him when they realised he had stopped breathing.

In her opening address to the court, Ms Ward said it was important for people to recognise the “profound loss” felt by Joe’s parents Danny and Elouise, who accompanied their son in hospital throughout the devastating ordeal.

“Joe was a funny little bundle of delight. Joe’s baby sister Annie, who has only recently joined the family, will never get to know Joe other than the stories that family and friends will share about him,” Ms Ward said.

“On Friday, September 13, 2024, Joe was his normal little self. He was still tearing around the house after his brother and sister and playing peekaboo with his mum in the kitchen.

“There was no reason to think he was anything but the happy and healthy little boy who had recently enjoyed a family holiday in Bali.”

Northern Beaches Hospital has since returned to full public administration. Image: NewsWire/Max Mason-Hubers.

Ms Ward went on to detail how Joe’s parents, upon realising he had been vomiting throughout the night, initially made a doctor’s appointment before calling triple-0 when they realised he was struggling to breathe and had an elevated pulse.

“Each an expert in their own child, [his parents] were better placed than anyone else to understand what was usual or unusual about Joe’s presentation,” Ms Ward said.

Ms Massa took her son to Northern Beaches Hospital, which had been operating as part of a public-private partnership between the NSW government and Healthscope, just after 7am on Saturday, September 14, 2024.

The nature of this partnership, brought in by a previous Coalition state government, became a source of significant controversy as allegations of staffing and procedural issues surfaced following Joe’s death.

One of the nurses who treated Joe said the digitised recording systems used by Healthscope formed part of the reason she and other hospital staff were unable to recognise his deteriorating condition.

Hilary O’Neill was the triage nurse who first greeted Ms Massa and her sick child when they arrived at Northern Beaches Hospital, and she initially registered Joe’s heartbeat as between 160 and 170bpm, which she said was “normal”.

Later, Ms O’Neill logged Joe as having a heartrate of 182bpm, which the digital triage system used by the hospital – known as WEBPAS – did not flag as a concerning level.

Ms O’Neill said in similar systems used by public hospitals at the time, a number of alerts would have flashed on the screen had the same heartrate been logged.

“There was no track or trigger systems in place to let me know he was in the red zone,” she said.

“He was pale, which isn’t uncommon in a child that’s presented with a large vomit and decreased intake.

“Throughout my interaction with Joseph’s mother and Joseph, he was calm and alert.”

Between 7am and 10.47am, Joe’s condition rapidly deteriorated as his mother interacted with several nurses and doctors, each of whom are legally represented as part of the inquest, before he ultimately regressed into cardiac arrest.

While the exact cause of Joe’s death is still a matter of discussion, it is believed an abdominal growth thought to have been caused by a build-up of fecal matter within his intestines was a major factor.

A critical misdiagnosis of Joe’s condition – thought at one point to be rudimentary gastroenteritis – will form part of the inquest.

The details of Mr and Ms Massa’s time in the hospital and how the nurses and doctors responded to Joe’s condition during that period will be the subject of intense scrutiny throughout the coming week.

Leave a comment