According to Monash University 2021, ‘Vicarious trauma’ (VT) describes the cumulative effects of exposure to information about traumatic events and experiences, potentially leading to distress, dissatisfaction, hopelessness and serious mental and physical health problems.
VT can directly impact a person’s emotional well-being when exposed to cumulative trauma. When you walk with people in crisis, it is inevitable that you will carry some of their pain.
Most people recognise that professions such as emergency services personnel (pre-hospital, search and rescue), law enforcement (the police service), plus fire and rescue services witness human suffering on a daily basis.
They deal directly with significantly challenging, traumatic and distressing events on a regular basis and are therefore prone to VT. Patients and clients trust healthcare professionals, disclosing their experiences of adversity to the clinician in detail.
Unfortunately, repeated exposure to traumatic events can take a heavy toll on healthcare workers.
However, people may be affected by VT that never directly face the distressing situation. Consider the administration team or data managers working in a trauma service, staff working in child protection units or at rape crisis centres who read documentation that contains distressing information.
They, too, are exposed to information, sometimes of a graphic nature relating to survivors of traumatic events and incidents.
There are many questions to consider in trying to understand vicarious trauma. Is VT a natural phenomenon? Does it affect all healthcare employees? Are some people more predisposed to VT than others? What we do know is that constant exposure is a risk factor.
Evidence suggests that it can affect anyone, administration staff, peer workers, clinical managers, executive directors and new or experienced workers.
It does not discriminate. Personal experiences of trauma, coping strategies, and work environment can all contribute to the effects of VT.
A colleague of mine maintains that VT is an inevitable consequence of working as a healthcare professional within a hospital and that only a naive person would refute this.
There are surgeons who are reluctant to upgrade their young child’s tricycle to a bicycle because of the potential handlebar injury to their abdomen in case their child falls while riding.
There are plastic surgeons who have refused to acquiesce to their children’s relentless request for a puppy to mitigate the risk of a dog bite.
Do ear, nose and throat surgeons and gastroenterologists store their dishwasher tablets in childproof containers to prevent horrendous burns to their children’s mouth and oesophagus after accidental ingestion? Is this not a form of VT?
Everyone responds to VT in different ways.
There is an inner transformation in the healthcare professional as a result of empathic listening. VT is usually associated with a negative connotation, where the healthcare clinician reacts negatively to the ongoing exposure to other people’s trauma.
VT can affect the clinician’s quality of life.
In fact, it can affect all aspects of one’s life – physically (from sleep disturbance and fatigue to abdominal pains and compromised immunity), psychologically (there may be heightened anxiety, intrusive thoughts, depression, avoidance and emotional exhaustion), cognitively (brain fog, headaches, difficulty concentrating), socially (some may experience difficulty separating personal and professional life, there may be relationship distancing) and behaviourally (one may exhibit irritability and anger, increased alcohol and drug use, absenteeism and avoidance).
People may change their attitudes and worldview and become more cynical or more risk-averse and fearful of activities.
Some people may have a neutral reaction to VT which implies the healthcare clinician’s tenacity, experience, support, and coping strategies are sufficient to manage the situation so that it has no perceptible negative effects.
Individuals may draw inspiration from their patient’s resilience, and that, in turn, strengthens their own mental and emotional fortitude.
Many clinicians develop an ability to survive and thrive, this is referred to as vicarious ‘post-traumatic growth’ or vicarious resilience.
This reflects the positive effects of adversity, trauma, and tragedy.
The clinician may have improved interpersonal relationships, greater self-perception, and insight. They adapt well in the face of hardship.
As a trauma nurse, I see injuries of varying severity every day, and consequently, I am aware of my own VT. For the most part, it takes the form of injury mitigation -
- I am aware of how I store and dispose of button batteries to prevent accidental ingestion, which may result in devastating internal burns and bleeding, and potential death.
- My blind cords do not dangle and become a strangulation risk.
- I advocate for using helmets with closed chin straps when cycling, using recreation devices or horse riding because I have seen too many traumatic brain injuries.
- I have my own amazing gentle dog, but I supervise closely when a child comes to pat my dog.
- I recommend swimming lessons from a very early age and wearing a life vest when on, or in the water to mitigate the risk of drowning.
- I highly recommend baby capsules and seat belts when travelling in motor vehicles. Correctly fitted baby capsules save lives.
- I have working smoke alarms in my home, and a tempering valve to regulate the hot water in my home to prevent inadvertent burn and scald injuries.
- I advocate that ride-on lawn mowers are used for the purpose that they were specifically intended to mow the lawn, because I have witnessed too many horrific injuries and amputations.
Personally, I use my VT to mitigate risks and unintentional injuries, but I do not let my VT stop me from participating in fun activities.
Professionally, I use health promotion and injury prevention education to counsel my patients and their families at every opportunity!
When we understand the impact of trauma and VT on others as well as on ourselves, we can use this knowledge to be kind, as well as competent in delivering the best possible care to those that need it.
We know that people have an innate capacity to heal themselves given the right support and a good work-life balance.
Some management strategies to promote vicarious ‘post-traumatic growth’ may include:
- Developing positive self-care routines, such as adequate nutrition, hydration, sleep, and exercise. Walking, running, dancing, gym, cycling – it does not matter, find something that you enjoy and incorporate it into to your daily life.
- Perhaps try a new approach to self-care, such as a yoga class, massage, mindfulness, meditation or Tai-Chi etc.
- Practise self-compassion and compassion for others in the workplace.
- Utilise self-awareness to identify your boundaries and your triggers for stress. When triggered, try changing the work assignment or shift; if possible, take time off or reduce your working hours; or perhaps become involved in a project of interest to you.
- Receive adequate training in areas related to work, including formal classes on relevant topics such as managing time, communicating effectively, and reducing stress.
- Frequently seek support, supervision, and mentoring from colleagues and peers.
- Develop and nurture supportive relationships with those around you.
- Review the resources that are available in your workplace, such as the employee assistance program or similar and know how to access these resources.
- Prioritise physical exercise and, when possible, get out in nature; both are known to help manage stress.
Vicarious ‘post-traumatic growth’ can foster a sense of hope for the future, which is essential for healthcare professionals to thrive and survive after direct and indirect traumatic experiences.
VT is a well-recognised phenomenon that impacts professions such as emergency services and health care clinicians over time if conscious steps are not taken to address this condition.
There are myriad online vicarious ‘post-traumatic growth’ training programs and applications, highlighting the prevalence of VT in our healthcare system.
Empowering healthcare professionals with the skills to promote vicarious ‘post-traumatic growth’ will enable clinician self-preservation and the ability to remain empathetic and compassionate, focused and optimistic about the future.
Tona Gillen currently works as the Trauma Nurse Manager at Queensland Children's Hospital.
