Chronic shortages of midwives in hospitals are causing various workforce issues, such as ineffective leadership and burnout – leading to a dire future for the midwifery workforce.
The Australian Institute of Health and Welfare reported a record number of babies being born in 2021, with an increase of 7 per cent.
However, last year, the National Skills Commission found that there were midwife shortages across the nation despite there being a 100 per cent future demand.
The Council of Deans of Nursing and Midwifery (CDNM) published a report listing six issues and recommendations to create a more supportive workforce while addressing leadership, burnout, continuity of care, professional development, and diversity challenges.
Nursing Review spoke with Griffith University Associate Professor Amanda Carter about the importance of addressing the paper to ensure the future of midwifery remained strong.
“It’s important because of the current workforce pressures and the need to transform maternity services to better meet the needs of women, their families, and their babies,” Professor Carter said.
NR: What does the future for midwives look like right now?
AC: I think the future of midwifery looks quite bleak if the problems are not addressed.
Midwives are becoming frustrated by their lack of autonomy in their roles, and they know they can make such a difference in outcomes for women and babies if they can provide continuity of midwifery care.
We know through insurmountable research and randomised controlled trials that midwifery continuity of care has significant improvements in outcomes for women and their babies.
We know that there are fewer premature births. We know there's less stillbirth. We know there are greater breastfeeding rates with midwifery continuity of care – and that's the model that a large majority of midwives want to work in, and they can work more autonomously.
Midwives are increasingly becoming frustrated at the over-medicalisation of birth and really want to use their skills to the full scope of practice.
What are the areas of improvement that are needed as soon as possible?
I think one of the areas that is desperately needed is a chief midwife nationally and also for each state.
We really need strong midwifery leadership.
At the moment, the people in the chief nursing and midwifery positions are generally nurses, and nursing and midwifery are two totally different disciplines. It's like comparing medicine to dentistry. They're two completely different disciplines.
We really need someone in that position who's going to have a strong voice politically and also have a strategic vision and ensure that all these other solutions can be implemented.
One of the main solutions is increasing midwifery continuity of care models and facilitating midwives to work that way.
It's what women want. It's a more economical model of care – and, as I said, it results in better outcomes.
The other thing that can be done immediately is to bring more midwives into the workforce.
Currently, I work at a university, so I'm involved in educating midwives for the future, and they face what we call significant placement poverty.
In a midwifery degree, they undertake 50 per cent of their degrees in practice. By going on placement, they also undertake continuity of care requirements where they follow women through their whole journey, meaning being on call for their labour and birth.
[This] really restricts what outside work you can undertake with clinical and being on call. They go to placement; they have to pay for petrol to get to placement, and they have to pay for parking at placement. Our students are currently really struggling with the increasing cost of living and affording to be able to do this degree. So, obviously, it's a priority area that we need more midwives, but they shouldn't be disadvantaged by starting midwifery. We need scholarships for students to undertake midwifery if the government's really serious about increasing numbers.
Also, obviously, we need to improve the cultural diversity of our workforce. So, looking at ways, again, for scholarships and encouragement for our First Nations people to become midwives so that we can provide adequate care and address some of the disparities in Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander women and babies and their mortality and morbidity.
There’s an increase in burnout among midwives, with research showing that 30 per cent were planning to leave their jobs in the next five years. What is being done to combat the shortages, as well as maintain retention?
Yes, so the five to seven years is a real pinch point post-graduation in midwifery.
I think some of the solutions to that is that we need some greater mentorship, continuity of care, and better staffing levels.
There's a project at the moment called Every Baby Counts, where they're talking about counting heartbeats.
Most maternity units, regarding staffing, count the mother and the baby as one unit rather than individuals. So that means that midwives can be responsible for up to 20 mothers and babies, one midwife. There's a campaign to count every heartbeat, which means you'd be counting the mother and the baby as separate because you're caring for two individuals. That's been trialled in Southeast Queensland with great success. Addressing those sorts of issues is going to help retain our current workforce.
As we know, midwives have been struggling in metropolitan areas, but what about rural and regional midwives?
They're really struggling.
You hear on the news and in the press all the time of rural midwifery services closing down, maternity services closing down, and women having to cover long distances.
Rural areas are an ideal place for midwifery continuity of care models to be established and to provide midwives with the opportunity to work that way.
However, we need incentives for students to undertake placement in rural areas and incentives for midwives to work in those areas.
We can't run maternity services without midwives.
Speaking of incentives, the government has put forward money for midwifery students to go to rural and regional areas. Is this enough?
I don't think it's enough.
I think for a student to leave their family in a metropolitan area and go to a rural area, pay for accommodation, uproot everything, and not be able to work – they might be leaving a paid job here. No, I don't think it is enough.
The government should increase those incentives and give students free accommodation and facilities for that to happen. Even a larger scholarship would help.
All these issues have now been put on the table, and it’s time for the government to step up with the solutions outlined in the paper.
