Skip to content Skip to sidebar Skip to footer

Why midwives and mothers are rallying over insurance

Midwives warn insurance changes could drastically reduce homebirth access across Australia.
Midwife professional indemnity insurance, homebirth

Homebirth advocates, midwives and mothers are ramping up pressure on the federal government ahead of nationwide rallies this weekend, warning that thousands of women could lose access to midwife-supported homebirths when a long-standing insurance exemption expires on December 31.

Advocates argue that a change to professional indemnity insurance requirements will have far-reaching consequences, particularly for women in rural and regional areas, where maternity options are already limited.

The Australian Nursing and Midwifery Federation (ANMF) has thrown its support behind Homebirth Australia’s ‘Grandmother of all Rallies’, with events going ahead in 25 towns and cities today under the banner of protecting birth choice.

A major national rally will also take place on Tuesday November 24 at Parliament House.

What is changing?

For years, privately practising midwives attending homebirths have operated under a special exemption from professional indemnity insurance requirements because a suitable insurance product was not available.

From January 1 2027, all midwives attending a homebirth will be required to hold professional indemnity insurance. The challenge, advocates say, is that the only available insurance product requires midwives to hold an Endorsement for Scheduled Medicines through the Nursing and Midwifery Board of Australia.

Obtaining that endorsement requires additional tertiary education and evidence of 5,000 hours of practice over the previous six years, and, according to the ANMF and the Australian College of Midwives (ACM), only about five per cent of Australia’s midwifery workforce currently holds it.

In Australia, a planned homebirth typically requires two midwives to be present: a primary midwife and a second midwife who assists and provides support during labour and birth.

While the primary midwife is usually endorsed, many second attendants are not.

The concern is that once the exemption expires, non-endorsed midwives will be unable to access insurance and therefore unable to continue working as second attendants at homebirths.

“No second midwives, no homebirth,” as Homebirth Australia puts it.

Related: Petition calls for urgent action on homebirth insurance gap

Why are advocates so concerned?

Homebirth Australia coordinator Katelyn Commerford told Nursing Review that the current insurance requirements focus on endorsement rather than the skills needed for the second-attendant role.

“The midwife who’s attending as a second at a home birth, the support they give is just your basic midwifery care,” she said.

“A midwife who is registered has already got the training, knowledge and skills needed to be able to support a woman in labor and birth.”

The ACM has made similar arguments, warning that the changes could force up to one-third of privately practising midwives out of the sector and lead some endorsed midwives to reduce their caseloads or close their books altogether.

ACM chief midwife Kelley Lennon said the exemption expiry will put “midwives out of work and women and babies at risk”.

“The current insurance conditions presented by the federal government are not fit for purpose and will destroy the private homebirth sector,” she said.

“Homebirth with a midwife is a safe choice. Midwifery continuity of care is evidence-based best practice, but despite all the proof in the world, the government is removing this access from women when they should be expanding it.”

The ANMF has also warned the changes could leave women with fewer regulated maternity care options and inadvertently drive some families towards unregulated alternatives.

Homebirth Australia coordinator Katelyn Commerford. Image: Supplied.

Rural communities could be hit hardest

Both the ACM and Homebirth Australia have highlighted that many regional areas have only one endorsed midwife available locally, with homebirth services relying on registered, but non-endorsed, midwives to act as second attendants.

Ms Commerford believes those services could disappear almost overnight.

“In rural and regional areas, we’re going to see home birth services completely decimated,” she said.

“There are plenty of places across the country where it’s just going to be unavailable overnight as of the first of January.”

For some women, homebirth offers access to continuity of midwifery care, a model associated with improved maternal and infant outcomes and one that may not be available through local hospitals.

“There’s a reason that women have chosen a homebirth for their babies,” Ms Commerford said.

“Often because the hospital is not safe, or not accessible to them for a myriad of reasons.”

A recent national survey by Homebirth Australia suggests the changes could have significant consequences for maternity care access. The survey found 88 per cent of non-endorsed second midwives would be forced to stop attending homebirths, while 60 per cent of privately practising primary midwives said they would be unable to continue offering homebirth services without access to an insured second attendant.

Many families also indicated they would continue to plan homebirths, even if a midwife could not attend.

Butler says safety must be balanced with choice

The federal government has acknowledged the concerns but maintains that all health practitioners should hold professional indemnity insurance.

Speaking to ABC News Breakfast on Tuesday, Health Minister Mark Butler said the exemption had originally been introduced because no insurance product existed for homebirth providers.

“An insurance product has now been developed and is offered to midwives, and as a result 18 months ago, health ministers across the country decided to bring midwives delivering home birthing services into line with every other health practitioner in the health system, and require them to hold insurance products if they’re delivering these services,” he said.

Mr Butler said governments had spent years working with the profession to develop a solution and argued that insurance requirements were a matter of safety.

“Having indemnity insurance is a bit of a no-brainer for health practitioners, particularly delivering services like birthing, given the huge consequences in those rare circumstances where things go wrong,” he said.

The minister also noted that endorsement requirements are determined by the Nursing and Midwifery Board of Australia, not by government.

Health Minister Mark Butler says insurance requirements are a matter of safety. Image: NCA NewsWire/Martin Ollman.

Touching on the issue again at a press conference in Nowra, Mr Butler said he was concerned about some families choosing freebirth over attending a hospital.

“MPs are talking to me about the fact that this may impact people’s sense of choice, particularly mums’ sense of choice, about the way in which they give birth,” he said.

“Obviously, we want to balance the question of choice with the need to ensure safety.”

What’s next?

Homebirth Australia is calling for an emergency extension of the current exemption while a more suitable insurance solution is developed.

Its preferred outcome is a temporary extension, followed by a permanent insurance model that allows non-endorsed second-attendant midwives to continue participating in homebirth services.

Today’s rallies will aim to increase public pressure on governments and force further action before the New Year’s Eve deadline.

“Women deserve the choice to birth where they feel comfortable and safe,” Ms Commerford said.

“Any sort of restriction of choice is putting mothers and babies at risk.”

Leave a comment