A petition signed by almost 6,000 Australians is calling on the federal government to intervene in a growing dispute over professional indemnity insurance arrangements for endorsed midwives attending homebirths.
Petition EN10266, launched by Alecia Staines and the Maternity Consumer Network, warned that insurance changes due to take effect from January 1 2027 could significantly reduce access to homebirth services, particularly in rural and regional parts of the nation.
The petition concerns the professional indemnity insurance requirements for the required second practitioner attending a homebirth. Under current arrangements, due to expire on December 31, a second attendant can be a hospital midwife, nurse with neonatal resuscitation training or an ambulance officer.
However, advocates says that from next year, insurance arrangements will effectively require second attendants to be endorsed midwives, as currently there is no indemnity insurance product for non-endorsed practitioners in that role. They are concerned that this will exacerbate workforce shortages outside metropolitan areas, where hospital midwives and other health professionals often act as second attendants at private homebirths.
Speaking in Parliament last week, Member for Wide Bay Llew O’Brien laid out the issues affecting midwives and those in the bush.
“This issue will be felt most acutely in rural and regional Australia, where maternity choices are already limited, services have been repeatedly centralised or closed and women can travel hundreds of kilometres simply to give birth,” he said.
“The Commonwealth does not need to dismantle an existing homebirth workforce in the name of insurance; it needs to ensure that workforce.
“For women in the metropolitan areas, these changes may reduce choice. For women in rural and regional Australia, they remove the choice altogether.”
He argued the current insurance product available through insurer MIGA was “not fit for purpose” because it did not provide a workable pathway for many experienced registered midwives who currently fulfil the second attendant role.
According to the petition, only 1,742 midwives nationally hold endorsement status, while a substantial proportion of current second attendants do not. Advocates say nearly half of Australia’s homebirths occur in rural and regional areas, making the existing arrangements particularly important for maintaining access.
The petition calls for a transitional exemption until 31 December 2027 and seeks an urgent roundtable involving the federal government, insurer MIGA, private midwives, professional organisations and maternity consumer groups.
Related: What drives women to have a ‘freebirth’? | NSW reports 10% midwife workforce growth | Vitamin K uptake falls as experts urge awareness | Nurses, midwives showcase skills at Parliament
Appearing on News24 Weekend NewsDay on Sunday, petition organiser Alecia Staines said the solution was straightforward.
“All they have to do is offer an insurance product to second attendees. They’re already providing a really safe service to support our private endorsed midwives. And all we want to happen is for that to be able to continue come 2027,” she said.
“It’s almost a slap in the face and the government’s saying, well, we’re happy for you to birth in the dirt on the side of the road, because that is the reality when there is this continued strip [out] of maternity options for women.”
When pressed on the issue, Assistant Mental Health and Suicide Prevention Minister Emma McBride said any governmental response would need to balance women’s choice with safety and professional protections.
“I think it's really about making sure that both women have choice and that practitioners and patients are protected,” she told News24 Weekend NewsDay.
“But I know the Minister and our government will always act in the best interests of women and practitioners.”
The federal government is yet to provide formal response.
