Skip to content Skip to sidebar Skip to footer

Nurses apologise to parents of toddler who died at NBH

The three nurses appeared at the inquest into the death of three-year-old Joe Massa and detailed systemic issues and broken equipment at the hospital

Nurses have apologised to the family of two-year-old Joe Massa as a coronial inquest continues to examine the events leading up to the toddler’s death at Northern Beaches Hospital in September 2024.

In emotional evidence last week, triage nurse Hilary O’Neill told the court she believed she had “played a role” in the circumstances surrounding Joe’s death and felt the family had been let down.

“I am so sorry. I am human, and I think about Joseph every day. I feel terrible that I missed his heart rate … I think I played a role, and the system let you down,” she said.

“This is a career I love, and I’m now terrified of it. I hope you get some closure and the answers you need.”

The admission came as the inquest continued its examination of Joe’s rapidly deteriorating condition in the hours before he suffered a cardiac arrest on 14 September 2024.

Earlier in the week, Elouise Massa told the court her son’s worsening condition was met with a “complete lack of urgency” from some hospital staff, despite her repeated concerns that he was becoming critically unwell.

Dispute over hospital alert systems

A focus of the inquiry remains the hospital’s electronic monitoring and escalation processes.

Ms O’Neill had previously given evidence that when she recorded Joe’s heart rate at 182 beats per minute, the hospital’s digital triage system did not alert her that the reading was in what is known as the “red zone”.

However, during further questioning by lawyers representing Healthscope, which operated the hospital at the time, Ms O’Neill’s recollection was challenged. Counsel for Healthscope David Lloyd suggested warning pop-ups would have appeared on the system.

“You’re mistaken about that,” he told the nurse.

Another nurse, Elaine Stork, was also questioned about the issue after she recorded Joe’s heart rate at more than 197 beats per minute while he was in the paediatric department.

Although she agreed she had concerns, Ms Stork told the inquiry she initially attributed part of the elevated reading to dehydration and Joe’s movement during assessment.

“I just attributed a bit of that to the dehydration and the fact he was squirming,” she said.

Ms Stork also apologised directly to Joe’s family.

“I’m sorry for what you guys have been through. I do wish I had taken more observations,” she said.

“I have reflected … I’m extra vigilant in my practice, and I’m happy about some of the changes that have come from this.”

Elouise Massa with husband Danny Massa. Image: NCA NewsWire/John Appleyard.

Senior nurse bypassed doctors

The inquest also heard evidence from senior emergency nurse Felicity Melville, who described Joe as “very unwell” when she assumed responsibility for the department at about 10am.

Ms Melville told the court she became concerned by Joe’s appearance, including “dark and sunken” eyes and mottled skin, while doctors were reportedly awaiting ultrasound results.

Believing Joe required more urgent intervention, she personally contacted the resuscitation team and arranged for a bed, rather than waiting for the normal escalation process.

“Joe was very unwell, he was lying on the bed,” Ms Melville said.

The court heard she transported Joe through the hospital to the resuscitation area without a doctor accompanying her, despite policy requiring medical staff to remain with a patient during a resuscitation transfer.

Moments after arriving, Joe went into cardiac arrest.

“I picked Joseph up and Mrs Massa said to me ‘my son is very sick’ and I said ‘yes he is’ and ‘I’m getting help’,” Ms Melville said.

“I was able to see Joe where I was standing, and that’s when Sam said that he had arrested.

“It was very quick”.

The inquiry was also told missing and faulty equipment delayed vital observations and monitoring in the time leading up to Joe’s death.

Ms Melville testified she was forced to leave Joe’s bedside three separate times, once for cables, once for stickers and once to make the call to resuscitation.

She said monitoring cables across the department were frequently broken or missing, forcing her to leave the bedside to search for functional ones.

She also faced difficulty when attempting observations on Joe’s heart rate, after changing the sticker.

“Sometimes it’s perfusion of the child,” Ms Melville said.

In another emotional moment, she addressed Joe’s parents directly.

“I am so deeply sorry for your loss,” she said through tears.

“Joseph mattered, and he matters now, and he will not be forgotten.”

Joe passed away on September 16, 2024 – two days after entering the emergency department.

Though his exact cause of death is unconfirmed, the inquest was told Joe died from bowel complications caused by a build-up of faecal matter, which hospital staff initially misdiagnosed as rudimentary gastroenteritis.

At the time of Joe’s death, Northern Beaches Hospital was operated under a controversial public-private partnership between the NSW Government and private provider Healthscope.

Following widespread outrage and campaigning by the Massa family, the state government returned the hospital to a full public administration, and overhauled clinical reporting policies across the public health system.

The inquest continues.

Leave a comment