Professor Enrico Coiera says his prediction that digitisation in healthcare over the past decade would lead to increased data-driven patient harm has come true.
Ten years ago the director of the Centre for Health Informatics at Macquarie University warned in his paper 'The Dangerous Decade' that technology innovation needed to go hand in hand with safeguarding digital health.
"Instead, we've seen a huge encroachment of digital health, especially in keeping electronic records around every level of healthcare delivery," he said.
Digital health involves using information and communication technology (ICT) in healthcare settings to improve patient wellbeing, such as telehealth and telemedicine.
Coiera foreshadowed that ICT deployed in healthcare over the past decade would amount to more than in the health system's entire history.
While data-driven healthcare has rapidly improved how we receive care, he said the progress may compromise digital health.
"And that was exactly what happened," he said.
"For many organisations worldwide, digital health safety is now a significant issue.
"If we don't pay attention to it, we can harm patients."
Data-related harm may result from human errors, wrong alerts and missing data within the system, or downtime where the network crashes or the power goes off.
Other events, such as the recent flooding in NSW and Queensland that impacted hospitals and GP practices, can also cause data breaches.
Personal records may be exposed to fishing and malware breach attempts during those moments.
Coiera said that while digitisation is now everywhere – from patient record systems like Medicare and mail merges that deliver test results – there are harms and benefits.
"It's a paradox in the relationship between technology and patient safety.
"Things go wrong for complicated reasons, but they do go wrong."
OAIC's annual report revealed that a fifth of all data breaches in the first half of 2021 occurred in the healthcare industry, leading OAIC to call it a 'cause for concern'.
Similarly, the Notifiable Data Breaches scheme said the sector has recorded the highest number of compromised data incidents for nearly four years.
Over 40 per cent of those reports were due to human error, a figure which has risen by 43 per cent compared to their last half-yearly report.
"Digital risks continue to be one of the largest risks many healthcare companies have," Coiera said.
"Negative outcomes have been rare, but we are now rolling out these systems on a scale that we've never seen before, and there is still a long list of things that can go wrong."
He said digital safety in healthcare is a complex issue where people need to use ICT under high work pressure.
"Clinical work can be very busy or chaotic.
"In the current Covid situation, people are also burned out and understaffed, so we know that when something goes wrong, it's never one thing.
"It's usually a chain of events that lead to the actual harm event or patient incident."
Although innovative technology has been implemented in many healthcare settings, older operating systems can be very clunky and slow.
"You might have a screen that's not so easy to navigate, so you might have a very busy and distracted nurse, who incorrectly enters data into the wrong field, causing the wrong drug to be given."
The healthcare sector has been facing significant workforce shortages, skyrocketing the work pressure on its staff.
Over 60 per cent of nurses reported their workload had increased during the pandemic, where just under half said they are working longer hours without adequate breaks.
Lacking the appropriate staff, healthcare workers have found ways to bypass slow systems to work more efficiently.
"I can give you a very famous one: when a nurse is administering medicine to patients in a ward, they're meant to scan the barcode," Coiera said.
"And so what nurses do to save time is to take all the barcodes and put them on their arm.
"Of course, that breaks the safety mechanisms embedded in checking the patient in front of you."
Yet, he also highlighted the need for more updated systems and staff training to smooth out the workflow.
While basic standards to operate ICT are being adopted in many healthcare settings, the workforce is still lacking user-friendly design and support.
"Usually, the electronic record systems we get are tough to change once they're in place, and often things we want to do just don't necessarily fit in the very old systems," Coiera said.
"We would love to see a more app-like world, where you can create specific tools in the system to assist different tasks, and they would be like apps and connect to an electronic record.
"Although this is being implemented in some areas, historically, innovation has been difficult because of the control the companies have had on design."
Coiera said that in the end, every clinician should put patient safety as the priority in all they do, whether they're busy or not.
"I think the biggest issue is for people to be more aware of the risks of using routine tools like electronic records and shortcuts.
"Every time we bring in a workaround or a shortcut because we are busy, short staffed or under pressure, we just have to be aware that that's not a risk-free decision."
He anticipates that the healthcare sector will face more challenges, including climate changes, mass heat and floods.
To cope with higher pressure, there needs to be a greater emphasis on researching ICT and protecting digital health.
"We can predict the sector will be under ongoing and evolving stress; there's no question that's the case.
"But it will depend on the context of what's going to happen, which will shape what we choose.
"It's very easy to be blinded by technology and by what we can do, but it's evident that something's going to have to change if we want to maintain the levels of care we currently give."
