Skip to content Skip to sidebar Skip to footer

Judge rules viral video cannot be used in trial of Sydney nurses

It has been excluded because, in NSW, it is illegal to record a “private conversation” or activity without the consent of the parties involved

A viral video in which two Sydney nurses allegedly threatened Israeli patients has been excluded as evidence ahead of their trial expected later this year.

Sarah Abu Lebdeh, 27, and Ahmad Rashad Nadir, 28, made international headlines last February after a video of the pair spread online in which they allegedly threatened violence against Israeli patients at Bankstown Hospital, in Sydney’s west.

On Tuesday, Judge Michael McHugh ruled the video be excluded from trial following a two-day hearing earlier this month where a court heard arguments about whether it was taken without the consent of the nurses.

“Ultimately, I have come to the firm view that all the video evidence must be excluded from each of the trials of the applicants,” he said.

In NSW, it is illegal to record a “private conversation” or activity without the consent of the parties involved, and carries a maximum sentence of five years imprisonment.

Ms Abu Lebdeh has pleaded not guilty to using a carriage service to menace, harass or offend and threaten violence to a group.

Mr Nadir has pleaded not guilty to using a carriage service to menace, harass or offend.

The pair remains on bail.

Sarah Abu Lebdeh (centre). Picture: NCA NewsWire/Nikki Short.

The video attracted criticism at the time, and made international headlines.

The pair, who have both been stood down from their jobs by NSW Health, have also been hit with a two-year ban from working with NDIS participants.

Outside court, Ms Abu Lebdeh said she was “grateful” for the court’s decision.

“I’m thankful for everyone that supported me, my friends and my family and my lawyer,” she told waiting media, according to the ABC.

Her lawyer, Rayan Kadidi, called the decision a “major victory” and said she did not think there was any evidence to charge her client.

She said Ms Abu Lebdeh ultimately lost her job and had experienced “severe hardship” as a result.

Zemarai Khatiz, acting for Mr Nadir, said the evidence had been excluded and the “prosecution case will collapse as a result of the exclusion”.

“[The prosecution] will also need to decide if they want to proceed with this charge or drop the case completely”,” he said, per reports from The Sydney Morning Herald.

Leave a comment