The most significant budget for a generation was handed down last week. After years of debate about how we should go about caring for our elders, now and into the future, this budget was to be the answer.
Much like the release of the final report of the Royal Commission into Aged Care Quality and Safety, the government's response was somewhat anti-climactic.
Aged care was of course mentioned in the treasurer's budget speech, but the official government response to the royal commission was released quietly on the health department website to no great fanfare.
The wider health sector was a key focus for the government after a year of pandemic-induced strain. The budget saw mental health, rural health and primary health all getting funding boosts.
The government said that an extra $1.8 billion will be invested in primary care, including:
- $50.7 million to continue to develop an ICT system that will enable a Voluntary Patient Registration Initiative, to be known as MyGP, which will lift the quality of services delivered to Australian patients through continuity of care.
- $301.8 million towards the next wave of My Health Record (MHR) capitalising on the connections already in place and ensuring a more coordinated healthcare future for Australia.
- $1.4 billion in high quality and person-centred mental health treatment, which includes the development of a national network of mental health treatments centres for adults, youth and children through the Head to Health and headspace programs.
- $27.8 million to grow the mental health workforce, including nurses, psychologists, allied health practitioners, psychiatrists, Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander mental health workforce, mental health peer workforce, practitioners in aged care, and promoting mental health as a career option within the health workforce.
The Government also committed $43 billion over four years to the Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme and $123 million in the rural health workforce and training.
Public hospitals funding is at $135.4 billion over five years according to the budget, up from $13.3 billion in 2012–13 to $25.6 billion in 2021–22 and $29.9 billion in 2024–25.
WHAT THEY SAID
The opposition
Opposition leader Anthony Albanese used his budget reply speech to take the Liberal Government to task for rejecting many of the royal commission's recommendations in last week's budget.
Albanese said that the budget ignored key reforms that would have a massive impact on the sector.
"The Prime Minister must now explain why he has rejected so many of those important recommendations," he said.
"Like the recommendation to require a nurse on duty in nursing homes at all times.
"Or support for increasing the appallingly low wages of hard-working aged care staff.
"Or why he’s opted for fewer hours of care than the Royal Commission recommended, and delivered them much later.
"Or why the Government is congratulating itself for funding new homecare places, when it isn’t even enough to clear the current waiting list."
Albanese said that a Labor government would strive to stop older people growing old "alone, deprived of proper care and dignity".
He said that his government would ensure that every dollar spent in aged care would go to employing a guaranteed minimum level of nurses, assistants and carers and the daily needs of residents, and not into "the pockets of the more unscrupulous providers".
"We also support the Fair Work Commission moving quickly to meaningfully lift the wages of aged care workers.
"And we will ensure that dementia care management is core business given that up to 2 in every 3 aged care residents is affected."
Australian College of Nursing (ACN)
ACN chief executive, Adjunct Professor Kylie Ward, applauded the government's $17.7bn outlay on aged care, in particular the $216.7 million investment in nursing scholarships, transition to practice programs and additional support for dementia and palliative care training for the workforce.
“Supporting more nurses to enter the aged care sector, as well as encouraging those who may not be able to access education to enter the sector by creating scholarships, will help to bolster the workforce as the changes from the Royal Commission into Aged Care Quality and Safety are implemented,” she said.
Ward also applauded the government's additional support for survivors of domestic violence.
The $1.1 billion package includes financial support for women and their children who leave a violent relationship and additional emergency accommodation for women and children experiencing family and domestic violence.
"This additional funding to support victim-survivors both in the moments of crisis and also in escaping from their abusers in the long term is, quite simply, doing the right thing to support vulnerable women and children,” Ward said.
“More support to care for the most vulnerable women and children in our community is a welcome support for the nursing profession who often directly support victim-survivors in the community.”
Australian Healthcare and Hospitals Association (AHHA)
AHHA chief executive Alison Verhoeven rates the budget a "3 stars out of 5" for healthcare investment.
"The $17.7 billion commitment to aged care over five years is about half of the investment recommended as being necessary by the Royal Commission into Aged Care Safety and Quality. It will make a difference, but attention will be required to ensure this investment makes a difference to the care of older people, not just to profit margins for private providers," she said.
"Much work is still needed to ensure aged care governance, safety and quality reforms aren’t neglected. Funding has been made available to support improved regulation – this work must commence immediately."
Verhoeven was pleased with the investment in mental health services and rural and regional health, but said that more needs to be done for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander health programs.
"Of the $2.3 billion allocated to mental health funding tonight, more than half ($1.4 billion) is notably to develop a network of Commonwealth-funded mental health centres, specialising in diagnosis and treatment of conditions in adults, youth and children.
"How these centres work together with Commonwealth-funded mental health programs administered by Primary Health Networks is not yet clear. It will be important to ensure that the majority of this large investment is directed at improved services and care for people with mental ill-health, and not just allocated to administration and infrastructure of new organisations.
"There is only a minor increase in expenditure on Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander health programs which is disappointing given the significant disparities in health outcomes experienced."
Australian College of Mental Health Nurses (ACMHN)
ACMHN president Dr Mike Hazelton believes that while the budget has given a welcome funding boost for mental health and nursing, including the $27.8 million allocated to increasing the number of nurses, psychologists, and allied health practitioners in mental health settings, not enough attention has been given to those too unwell for primary care, but not unwell enough for state-based services.
“This is a major omission that needs to be addressed in government initiatives to rebuild the Australian mental health system from the ground up,” Hazelton said.
“I would like to join others who have commented on the very poor state of mental health care in Australia and acknowledge the importance of the $2.3 billion allocation to mental health in the budget. I take this as an expression of goodwill by the Government heeding the recommendations that many reports and individuals in the mental health sector have been putting forward.”
The unions
Carolyn Smith, aged care director of the United Workers Union said the budget gives the illusion of action on aged care but fails to address fundamental issues facing the sector.
“In residential care, when you look at the promise of care time for older Australians, it’s being introduced with the lightest feather of regulatory enforcement: an obligation to report care time minutes in July 2022.
“The aged care sector knows what this is about: no-strings-attached funding for providers and no clear expectation that money will be meaningfully tied to care for older Australians.
“In home care clearing the waiting list over two years simply means older Australians will continue to die on the waiting list.
“Scott Morrison has broken his promise for a comprehensive response to the aged care crisis by rejecting the Royal Commission’s recommendation that the home care wait list be cleared by the end of the year."
Smith said that the $17.7 billion a year over five years – or $3.5 billion a year – paled in comparison to the $50 billion in funding needs indicated by the Royal Commission and others over the same period.
“In its final report the Royal Commission found Federal Government funding in 2018–19 was $9.8 billion lower annually than it should be if aged care had been appropriately funded,” Smith said.
“The funding shortfall is leading to horrendous human costs in aged care, with older Australians left unsafe and vulnerable, and workers left physically and emotionally exhausted."
The Australian Nursing and Midwifery Federation is similarly unmoved by the government's package. It welcomes the measures ensuring providers must disclose care minutes as well as the new aged care act, but said that this alone is not enough.
“We question which generation will actually see the benefits of any action the government is taking to fix aged care. This budget falls well short of what residents, their families and the community wanted to fix this broken system,” federal secretary Annie Butler said.
"We’ve always said, if you don’t fix staffing, you can’t fix the aged care system. So the announcement of 200 minutes of minimum care per resident is a step in the right direction, but why wait until 2023? Critically, it does not include any requirement for a registered nurse to be on site at aged care facilities.
"Without mandated minimum staffing levels and skills mix guaranteed to meet the care needs of residents, elderly Australians and their families will continue to suffer."
