A new report claims that the public sector 'wages cap' enforced by the NSW Treasury between 2011 and 2023 has had a profoundly detrimental effect on the remuneration of nurses and midwives, resulting in a labour market in NSW under significant strain.
The report examines wage movement between 1999 and 2024 and was prepared for the NSW Nurses and Midwives’ Association (NSWNMA) by Professor John Buchanan, an expert in labour market and industrial relations from the University of Sydney.
Professor Buchanan describes the cap of 2.5% as "ruthless", stressing that now is the "time to listen and act".
Shaye Candish, NSWNMA general secretary, says Professor Buchanan's investigation shows just how damaging the wage suppression has been.
“The pay disparity [between states] paints a dire picture of just how far behind nurses and midwives’ wages are thanks to the former government’s wages policy and the impact of inflation. In NSW, nurses and midwives are now the second worst paid in the country when starting their career,” said Ms Candish.
“When compared to Queensland, new graduates are 18% worse off, while the highest level registered nurses are 8% behind on pay.
“Public sector workers like teachers, paramedics and firefighters are paid significantly more than entry level nurses and midwives – their pay also lags behind almost all other professional and male dominated non-professional occupations.
“The situation is even more bleak when cost of living pressures are taken into account. Sydney is the most expensive city to live in, yet the nurses and midwives on whom they rely on are struggling to pay rent and mortgages.”
Professor Buchanan argues that a one-year wage increase of 15.2% for nurses and midwives within the public sector is justified.
"In real terms their wages have fallen by over 10% since 2020," he said.
He says because of the spike in inflation after Covid that all the wage rises of the last 10 years were wiped out, and a larger pay rise is needed to address this.
"It is time to escape the curse of NSW Treasury’s wage cap and begin the move to wage levels that are compatible with a sustainable nursing and midwifery labour market."
The NSWNMA has now submitted its claim to the NSW state government as part of the 2024 Public Health System Nurses’ and Midwives’ Award seeking:
- a 15% wage rise for nurses and midwives from July 1, 2024
- improvements to conditions including increases to night shift penalty rates and sick leave
- additional funding for minimum staffing ratios.
NSWNMA assistant general secretary Michael Whaites knows that significant changes are required within the sector.
“The report highlights that there have been heavy losses from both inflation and the unfair distribution of previous productivity gains," Mr Whaites said.
“It’s clear that if this inequity isn’t addressed, our state’s nursing and midwifery workforce will continue its bleak trajectory of high staff turnover, workforce fatigue and compromised patient care, as management struggles to fill the gaps.
“Low wages are driving inefficiencies in the healthcare system through high cost of agency, overtime and staff replacement as nurses and midwives leave the system, and at the end of the day it’s our patients that are missing out."
