Skip to content Skip to sidebar Skip to footer

Telehealth not enough to replace in-person palliative care: Q&A

As the pandemic fostered the demand for telehealth, a team of researchers asked themselves…

As the pandemic fostered the demand for telehealth, a team of researchers asked themselves whether it stood a chance in replacing real-life palliative care services.

Following 130 palliative care patients, the two studies revealed that 91 per cent of patients and doctors thought telehealth was acceptable and 72 per cent said it was satisfactory in most situations.

Professor Jennifer Philip from the University of Melbourne said it offers new opportunities but can't substitute in-person palliative care.

"We were a little surprised to find such high satisfaction rates, particularly in people living in rural and remote parts of Australia," she said.

"Telehealth served well when it was a routine check-up and health was stable.

"But when someone was experiencing a lot of pain and distress, people said that telehealth was insufficient to address the issues properly."

Nursing Review asked Jennifer what patients enjoyed about using telehealth during their palliative care meet-ups, and what aspects were still lacking to replace the personal doctor-to-patient connection.

NR: How did you come by the connection between palliative care and telehealth, and what did you find in your study?

JP: Like everyone else with the lockdowns across Australia, telehealth became something we previously had small amounts of experience with. But suddenly, we had to use telehealth in all care provisions.

It was interesting to think how this would be adopted and adapted to palliative care. A lot of what we do is around relationship building and helping people explore their understanding of the illness, what's going on, and what they hope for.

These are often reasonably important existential things, so having a good relationship between doctor and patient is vital to the success of palliative care.

I was among a few who were a bit sceptical about how this could work in palliative care, and we saw an opportunity to research whether it would work well or not and, if so, for whom it would work best or work least well.

So we undertook a mixed method study: we had two approaches. One was a survey after people had had a telehealth consultation with their doctor. We asked both the doctor and the patient to answer a series of questions about how well it worked, and what they thought went well, and how satisfied they were or not.

Then we also carried out interviews both with doctors and patients. Some of the things that we found were perhaps not surprising. For example, we found that people from regional and rural areas thought telehealth was fantastic.

But we were a little surprised that we found a high level of satisfaction and high acceptability. Interestingly, both doctors and patients were quite satisfied with palliative care through telehealth. Patients were more likely to find it acceptable and satisfactory than their doctors, but there was a series of things where they thought it worked very well, and some things didn't work so well.

So, they thought it worked well if it was just a routine appointment when there were no urgent or problematic concerns that needed to be addressed — particularly for people living in rural or regional parts of Australia.

They're less likely to be satisfied if their health was unstable. So patients and their doctors thought that if the pain was a bit problematic, other symptoms were alarming, or people were distressed, telehealth was insufficient. Patients didn't like it if it needed to be a significant communication type of consultation. If it was exploring plans and goals for the future, they didn't think it was such a great medium.

The qualitative work was interesting because that showed that telehealth enabled more follow-up and continuity of care between patients and their doctors. Mindful that this was when a lot of the community palliative care services were under the pump.

Sometimes if people were getting sicker, and normally, you would not keep asking people to come back to appointments because it's a burden and hard work. Instead, you would refer those patients or ask for their community support, their community palliative care, to take on the primary mantle of care.

But because community palliative care was pretty stretched during Covid, and also because telehealth enabled even people who were quite frail to have ongoing relationships with their doctors, telehealth facilitated that access – which was a bit of a surprise. 

During our studies, we could follow people for longer because they didn't have to come to the hospital. So we often try to make it easy for people in terms of their appointments; if they were coming to the hospital for a set of scans or those sorts of things, in the usual world, we would see people at those times because they're at the hospital already, rather than asking them to come back on a separate occasion to see us.

Another positive aspect of telehealth was that it strengthened the connection between patients and their palliative care doctor. Typically, when someone needs to go to a hospital for a medical appointment, their usual palliative care doctor might not be available. So that would mean that they'd see a different doctor, whereas with telehealth, they would come and have their scans, but then they would see their usual doctor by telehealth on the other day. So, it enabled continuity in that way as well.

So it made accessing palliative care easier and enhanced the connection between the palliative care doctor and the patient? 

Absolutely. It makes it easier for the patient to have the same ongoing relationship with the person and to access the healthcare as you say. They're not spending half their day going to the hospital. 

In hospitals, you have to walk around a lot, and there are always distances and long waiting times. So if you're not feeling well, that might be the tipping point that you think, 'Oh, I'm not up for it today.'

Indeed, we asked patients, and several respondents said, 'If it had meant that I had to come to the hospital, I would have had to cancel my appointment because I wouldn't be feeling well enough.'

How likely is it that palliative care using telehealth will be incorporated more in the future?

I think the success would be a combination of both because of telehealth's downsides. If people had new or challenging symptoms, then patients didn't rate the telehealth service so highly. Many of them were done on the phone rather than via a visual sort of medium, such as Zoom. And it's not nearly so good on the phone.

In that case, it's harder to understand what's going on fully. You can't see each other's expressions. Especially for people where English may not be the first language, we use many visual cues to help us understand the intention of what's being said, and you can't get that on the phone.

The other downsides of using the phone – because we use phones so much throughout our day-to-day lives – people said they lost the formality of the appointment if it was on the phone. They weren't ready for it, or they hadn't got themselves thinking about what questions they wanted to ask.

Sometimes they might be out walking the dog or at the shops, and suddenly they'd forgotten about their telehealth appointment. They also talked about how seeing people face-to-face is much more reassuring; that the personal relationship offers a lot of reassurance and safety.

I think some combination going forward is likely the best, but we need to add structure to that. The appointments are giving us two different ways of having a consultation, and both of them have potentially got benefits, but we need to get the most out of both.

So, perhaps every third consultation should be another in-person check-in or some regular opportunity to reengage in that interpersonal way.

On the other side, though, could the loss of formality help enhance the doctor-to-patient relationship?

Yes, potentially. If patients are in their own homes, they may feel more comfortable doing that. So I think both ways have potential benefits, and we need to work out how to do it properly.

I think the other thing is that we must ensure that we support people to access telehealth, not just telephone health. Because there are also people who can't afford broadband or don't have the data on their phone to have visual consultations.

We need to be aware of that and have the proper support and infrastructure to enable people to access it fully.

Leave a comment