Does the way in which a doctor describes a medical condition influence our decision making?
Researchers from the University of Sydney believe that it does, and found that in some cases the terminology used could make people up to 25 per cent more likely to get surgery.
Looking specifically at shoulder pain, the study by Dr Joshua Zadro, Dr Brooke Nickel, Dr Giovanno Ferreira, Dr Mary O'Keeffe, and Dr Tessa Copp from the University of Sydney involved 1,308 people from five countries, some with and without shoulder pain.
They were allocated to read one of six scenarios, the only difference between each one was the term used to describe the person's shoulder pain. They used the most common type of shoulder pain where people feel pain at the front of one of their shoulders, which is made worse by lifting the arm and lying on it.
This pain is often described synonymously as "subacromial impingement syndrome” or “rotator cuff tear”, “bursitis”, and “rotator cuff related shoulder pain”.
Writing about their work in The Conversation, the researchers say that doctors often use a wide range of terms for this shoulder pain, mainly "because it’s currently impossible to pinpoint the exact cause of most shoulder pain".
They found that people who had “rotator cuff tear” were more likely to want surgery. In fact, they had 24 per cent higher perceived need for surgery than those told they had "bursitis", the group with the least perceived need for surgery.
Negative vibes
Semantics is thought to play a role in the perception of other conditions as well.
The USyd team writes that wording can affect the way we see types of cancer, acid reflux, polycystic ovary syndrome and even pink eye.
They point to research that asked parents to consider a hypothetical scenario in which their otherwise healthy infant cries a lot and “spits up excessively”. Parents who were told their child had "gastroesophageal reflux disease", the fancy term for acid reflux, were more likely to want medication.
Another study looking at a scenario where parents were either told their child had an "eye infection" or alternatively "pink eye" (both terms meaning conjunctivitis), found that the pink eye group perceived the infection as more contagious and were more interested in antibiotics even when informed that they wouldn't help.
Reframing the narrative
The researchers argue that health professionals should be mindful of the words they use, and although it may be a challenge to change oft used terminology, it would save on needless patient anxiety and unnecessary surgeries could be avoided.
In the instance of shoulder pain, this might save the 20,000-plus potentially unnecessary shoulder surgeries that are performed in Australia each year, which they estimate to cost over $200 million per year.
"Changing how health professionals describe conditions to their patients is a simple strategy that could curb the rise of unnecessary health care," they write.
"For patients with shoulder pain not caused by severe trauma, we suggest health professionals avoid telling patients they have rotator cuff tears as this may make some patients think shoulder surgery is needed (which it isn’t).
"Health professionals could instead label people with this type of shoulder pain as having bursitis (inflammation), as this was the label that mostly made people think surgery was unnecessary."
