Nearly two years into a global pandemic, and with catastrophic bushfires before that, nurses are at an emotional breaking point and less willing to work, according to researchers.
Research from Edith Cowan University (ECU) has found that the healthcare workforce are less willing to work than before the pandemic.
ECU researcher Associate Professor Erin Smith says that with concerns ranging from availability of personal protective equipment (PPE), family members’ worries, and risk of contracting the virus, healthcare staff are thinking twice about their profession.
“As the pandemic continues, the risks of the ongoing physical, psychological and emotional toll on frontline workers and their families are of great concern," she says.
The study, which surveyed healthcare workers, was conducted during the first wave of COVID-19, but the issues remain, the researchers say.
“Organisations may have improved their processes and procedures from what they were at the start of the pandemic, but we have to weigh this against factors such as fatigue and burnout,” Smith says.
“Back during Australia’s first wave of community transmission, one third of participants reported at least one symptom of burnout (35 per cent), 30 per cent had symptoms of depression and 16 per cent disclosed absenteeism."
Back in April 2020 Smith, a Professor of Disaster and Emergency Response, predicted that an uncontrollable pandemic may see healthcare workers simply walk off the job.
At the time Smith said coming off the back of an unprecedented bushfire season, nurses were stretched to the limit. And in terms of PPE, Australia had used up a huge amount of our existing stockpile, particularly in terms of the face masks exacerbating the fear amongst staff – these predictions did come to bear.
"We found that 42 per cent of our respondents were less willing to work and less willing to be doing those jobs that they were doing before the pandemic," she told Nursing Review recently.
She says the findings of her study were early on in the pandemic and she predicts that after nearly two years, many doctors and nurses will be at breaking point.
"You can only imagine with the ongoing onslaught, particularly here on the east coast that we've experienced in New South Wales and Victoria, that we're now dealing with additional issues like burnout and moral distress and anxiety and PTSD. If anything, I think if we were to replicate that research right now, which is actually our plan, I think we would see those rates increase.
"I've been speaking to colleagues and friends right across the healthcare workforce, particularly in New South Wales. These are lifelong career frontline workers here, 20, 30 years of experience. They're expressing to me that they can't keep going on, that many of them are actively looking for other jobs. Some of them have already left the workforce and this was a career they thought they would be in for life."
Smith's research found that three quarters of respondents said they had wrestled with their obligation to work and the risk of infecting themselves and their families.
And while most healthcare workers said it was acceptable for them to face some level of risk of exposure to infectious diseases in their workplace, 35 per cent said they disagreed such as risk was acceptable.
Adding to that fear and confusion is the effect that the last two years have had on a healthcare workers' sense of self.
“When healthcare workers compromise their core values, they can feel shame, guilt, and even isolation,” Smith says.
“Unresolved moral distress can result in experiencing depression and other mental, emotional and spiritual health struggles.
“The nursing profession, in particular, anticipates a high rate of post-pandemic staff exodus, largely due to accumulated and unresolved moral distress.”
Going forward Smith says that authorities urgently need to address many of the fears that staff face, especially as we look to deal with COVID-19 in the community long-term.
Providing safe accommodation away from the home for staff who may have been exposed is one idea, as is making sure there is access and timely access to the required PPE 24/7, she says.
"We also certainly need to re-look at the way we are providing wellbeing support to people on the frontline," she says.
"We cannot keep expecting people, when they are mentally exhausted and potentially in crisis, to reach out for help. We need to be finding methods and systems that routinely reach in to people to identify those who are struggling."
And if we don't address these issues soon, the great resignation may come to fruition.
"The hard part is there's no end in sight. Our politicians and leaders keep referring us to, 'oh, well the double vaccines, that's the only thing we need to worry about', but that's great in terms of a goal for opening up," Smith says.
"But that has nothing to do with how long the effects of the pandemic will actually last for. If we look at other big disasters, like the black Saturday bushfires in 2009, we know that these effects can last for well over a decade.
"We're going to see a mass exodus of staff and I've seen various figures reported around the world, but some are suggesting up to 25 to 30 per cent of the frontline workforce will quit and never come back."
