Eleven months, 4000 submissions, and six hearings later the final report for the inquiry into NSW birth trauma has been released.
The Select Committee on Birth Trauma released its 256-page report last week with five findings and 43 recommendations to try and prevent more people from suffering trauma during pregnancy and childbirth.
Marked as a "significant milestone", the report stated the inquiry "reflected the growing recognition of the importance of addressing this form of gendered violence".
"Our hope is that the evidence documented in this report will not only inform the NSW Government's consideration of these matters, but more importantly, prompt action across Australia and the world with the hope that every birth is met with dignity, respect and compassion."
Five findings
The committee found that there are a "number of individuals who have suffered preventable birth trauma in NSW", with the evidence during the inquiry "distressing and unacceptable".
"The large scale of submissions received speaks to the impactful and complex nature of birth trauma for the individual giving birth, their support people, the health practitioners involved, and the broader community," the report said.
"We must do better."
The second finding was that urgent efforts should be made to address "avoidable and preventable factors" that contributed to birth trauma.
The inquiry was labelled the "MeToo" moment for birth by Hannah Dahlen, a professor of midwifery at Western Sydney University, with some mother losing their babies and others carrying their babies and physical and mental traumas home.
"No means no, except apparently in childbirth, and it’s time to change that," Professor Dahlen said during one of the hearings at Wollongong.
"This is the MeToo movement of birth."
Thus, the third committee finding was the violent nature of some of the births, with the committee citing that UN had recognised certian cases of birth trauma to be considered as gendered violence.
Clear and comprehensive education was needed for all aspects of pregnancy and childbirth, which would therefore lead to fully informed consent.
During the last hearing in Sydney, Cassidi-Rae Amosa gave evidence of her PTSD experience following her birth, which included multiple strokes nine days post-partum, despite being only 21.
"After giving birth to my youngest child, my placenta split and got caught and was unable to pass by itself," Ms Amosa told the inquiry.
"Rather than sending me to the theatre, after multiple attempts of pushing out the remains of the placenta by pushing down on my stomach, the doctor decided to perform the most inhumane procedure I've ever heard, and quite frankly, it still gives me nightmares and flashbacks."
Ms Amosa then detailed how the doctor had given her gas for the pain, and then "her whole fist entered" her vagina to remove the placenta without asking for consent or explaining what was happening.
"I was violated. There's no other word for it. No is no. It's non-consensual. It's disgusting. I would put it in the same category as rape."
The committee stated it was "imperative" for healthcare providers to "foreshadow" any potential interventions, ideally well before the birth.
"The committee was particularly concerned about stories of women who felt forced into procedures without adequate information or time to consider their options," the report stated.
"The committee calls on the NSW Government to consider this issue as a matter of urgency."
The final finding was that a "one-size-fits-all" approach was inadequate.
Recommendations
Continuity of care
Of the 43 recommendations, the committee gave priority to ensuring all women had access to continuity-of-care models with a known provider.
"Midwifery continuity of care was identified as the ‘gold standard’, which is why the report also recommends the NSW Government invest in and expand midwifery continuity-of-care models, address midwifery shortages and appoint a standalone Chief Midwifery Officer."
Currently, only one in 10 women in NSW have access to this model.
Submissions during the inquiry reported many wanted to "opt-in" for the continuity-of-care and Midwifery Group Practice (MGP) models, but due to lack of places or "high-risk pregnancies" they were excluded.
"Ms Olivia Prain was initially accepted into MGP and then later excluded," the committee wrote.
"She told the committee that she 'had felt really safe in the program' and was disappointed to no longer be part of it.
"She was mostly worried about seeing a multidisciplinary team of doctors and midwives as she feared issues could be missed and she could 'slip through the cracks' of the public health system."
The NSWNMA said that midwifery-led continuity of care should be accessible to all, especially those who are deemed at a high-risk.
"Despite being the gold standard, only a small fraction of women in NSW who birth are able to access this model of care and access is almost always contingent on the woman possessing a high level of education and awareness that the model of care exists and early booking (at 4-5 weeks) is necessary as well as being sufficiently ‘low risk’ to be eligible for a place," a spokesperson said
The committee, however, stopped short of recommending universal access to MGP – something advocates had been calling for.
Workforce shortages and trauma
Addressing workforce shortages was also a priority in ensuring trauma was minimised for those giving birth and healthcare professionals.
Professor Dahlen highlighted that the trauma experienced by midwives and obstetricians through their work had also contributed to workforce shortages.
Data from the Nursing and Midwifery Board found the workforce in NSW to have a nine per cent decline from 2021 to 2023.
There was also a 9.7 per cent decrease in the number of midwives with seven years or more experience between 2018 to 2022.
Fewer experienced midwives meant that junior midwives were now struggling to find mentorship, meaning new graduates were leaving the industry quicker.
Chief Midwifery Officer
The job of a chief midwifery officer – a role that exists in Queensland and the UK – would be a good first step in helping to tackle a shortage of maternity health services.
"The role of a chief midwife would be to give advice to government, would be to be looking at what's happening on the ground, would be around putting into place support programs that are around sustaining the midwifery workforce, that are about growing that midwifery workforce, that are about putting evidence into practice and advocating for that profession," Professor Dahlen said.
However, Labor member and committee member Emily Suvaal opposed the appointment of a chief midwifery officer "without seeking to undertake a review of the evidence available to support this investment".
"We do not believe the inquiry sufficiently established a case to support appointing an additional high-paid executive in NSW as the best use of resources," Ms Suvaal said in the report.
"Equally we believe a fiscally responsible approach would include a review of the progress already achieved to strengthen senior midwifery representation in the NSW Government."
"Disappointing": Committee members react to report
Some of the committee members were disappointed at the lack of support for some services and the recommendations given.
Deputy chair and Liberal party member Susan Carter welcomed the report and its recommendations, but was concerned for mothers receiving diagnoses of foetal abnormalities.
"To feel the excitement of pregnancy, and then to learn that there is a medical issue with the child you are carrying can be overwhelming," Ms Carter said.
"And it is clear that the way in which this news is delivered and the follow up care can be very traumatic for a number of expectant mothers.
"It is paradoxical for a society to extend care and a welcome to all people living with a disability, but only after birth and not during pregnancy."
Chair of the committee Emma Hurst said that she felt "compelled to put on the record" that several of her recommendations were "watered or voted down" by fellow commitee members.
"I want every parent reading this report to know that your voices were heard by me," Ms Hurst said.
"I want every survivor of birth trauma to know that these are the recommendations, along with those formally in the report, that I will continue to fight for.
"I heard you loud and clear."
Ms Hurst's recommendation's included that the state government develop a NSW Patients Bill of Rights which would include protection from obstetric violence, and audio or video recordings in birthing suites.
"This would have gone a long way to protect birthing parents from birth trauma," Ms Hurst said.
"It is beyond me why patients having recognised rights is considered controversial."
Other recommendations by Ms Hurst included ensuring all women have access to continuity of care models with a known provider – which the committee changed to "of their choice" – and investment and expansion of MGP instead of midwifery continuity of care models.
NSW Health Minister Ryan Park welcomed the report, and praised the adovcates and mothers who gave testimony.
"I'm very pleased that the report was handed down," Mr Park said.
"We as a system now will carefully and methodically work through this and respond.
"Work has begun to improve the system, with a NSW birthing and maternity blueprint underway, an expert advisory group, and a consumer group in place."
The NSW government is expected to respond to the report by August 29.
