Skip to content Skip to sidebar Skip to footer

Former nurse found guilty of attempting to murder her husband

A former nurse accused of trying to carry out a "mercy killing" on her…

A former nurse accused of trying to carry out a "mercy killing" on her husband has been found guilty of attempted murder in the WA Supreme Court.

Last week, the jury found Wendy Ruth Sym, 63, had attempted to murder her husband of almost 40 years in January 2021 after he was admitted to hospital suffering advanced dementia.

Kenneth William Sym had become "increasingly disoriented" and had a fall shortly before he was admitted to Joondalup Health Campus in WA.

The following day, Mr Sym experienced a series of medical episodes, later diagnosed by doctors and toxicology reports as hypoglycemia, marked by critically low blood sugar levels, often resulting from an insulin injection.

Ms Sym was seen on CCTV leaving the hospital at 1:45pm and returning shortly before 5pm.

The court heard she had asked a staff member not to perform the usual observations while she was gone.

A doctor has also issued a "do not resuscitate" order after a discussion with Ms Sym.

However, after discovering Mr Sym's extremely low blood sugar, medical staff administered a drug and performed interventions that saved his life.

After Ms Sym returned to the hospital, the court heard one of the nurses thought she was acting strange.

Ms Sym then used a nearby toilet, after which a nurse claimed she found a vial of insulin in the wastepaper basket in the cubicle used by Ms Sym.

The vial was written on 9 April 2018, indicating it had been opened more than two years prior.

Prosecutor Adam Ebell told the court the brand was not used at Joondalup Health Campus but at Princess Margaret Hospital, now Perth Children's Hospital, where Ms Sym had worked as a nurse in 2018.

Mr Ebell had said it would have been "simple" for Ms Sym to administer the insulin as she was a registered nurse.

He said a DNA test showed two profiles on the vial, including those of Ms Sym.

The court was also shown a text message Ms Sym sent just before midnight on January 12, 2021, in which she described having been awoken by Mr Sym "talking nonsense", refusing to get into bed, and emptying the refrigerator's contents.

"He has pulled out a box under the bed and stuff is everywhere," she wrote.

"I honestly could kill him. I won’t, of course.

"Give me a 12-hour night shift with no sleep rather than this."

The state argued that Ms Sym had attempted to carry out a "mercy killing" of her husband and that while the evidence was circumstantial, she had the opportunity and motive to administer a fatal dose.

Mr Sym survived the incident but died of natural causes two months later.

The state did not seek to argue the attempted murder was in any way linked to his subsequent death.

Ms Sym's defence lawyer, Seamus Rafferty SC, told the court the DNA evidence was not conclusive and that no one had witnessed Ms Sym inject her husband.

He put to the jury that it was unlikely Ms Sym would wait until her husband was in the hospital to make an attempt on his life.

Ms Sym was also not alone with her husband at any point in the window of time a toxicology report indicated she would need to have injected him in.

He also criticised the investigation, saying a key witness was not interviewed until a week before the start of the trial.

Mr Rafferty pointed out it was unlikely she would return to the scene of the crime still carrying the murder weapon and dispose of it nearby.

He questioned why, if she had obtained a vial of insulin from her workplace, she would wait years before using it.

Mr Rafferty said that although Ms Sym did not deny the challenges of caring for her husband in the late stages of dementia, she remained devoted to him and was actively arranging measures to enable her to continue providing care for him at home.

He also said that she chose to give evidence and be cross-examined and argued this lent her account more credibility.

"This was a woman who was prepared to tell you everything, warts and all … even if it was adverse her interests," Mr Rafferty said.

At the same time, he questioned the reliability of the evidence from the nurse who found the vial.

Mr Rafferty also pointed out that when Ms Sym had left the hospital that afternoon, she was shopping for clothes for her husband, which was "hardly" the conduct of someone who had just injected her husband with a potentially lethal dose of insulin.

The jury deliberated for more than eight hours before returning a guilty verdict.

Ms Sym will be sentenced at a later date.

Leave a comment