The nursing and midwifery workforce is the largest group of regulated health professionals representing approximately 60 per cent of the registered workforce in Australia, and contributes significantly to the health outcomes of individuals, families and communities. As the COVID-19 pandemic continues to rage around the world, a common refrain has highlighted both a health workforce shortage and an increased sense of the value and importance of nursing and nurses.
During the pandemic, nursing workforce shortages have been experienced globally in high, middle and low-income countries, and messages of desperation expressed with many nurses intending to leave the profession.
The State of the world’s nursing 2020 report has provided data on the nursing workforce using information obtained from the National Health Workforce Accounts. This report has been an important stocktake to inform coordinated human resources for health strategy globally. Yet as in many instances, the availability and quality of data can influence conclusions made and as a consequence workforce projections. In spite of limitations, these data from 191 member states of the World Health Organization provide a persuasive case for investment in nursing education, jobs and leadership.
This report identifies there is not a shortage of nurses in Australia, but we can’t help but feel it doesn’t feel like that and this view and sentiment extends beyond the immediate crisis of the pandemic.
Workforce planning projections show that in the medium to long-term, Australia’s demand for nurses will significantly exceed supply with a projected shortfall of approximately 85,000 nurses by 2025, or 123,000 nurses by 2030.
There are also worrying issues around the nature of the nursing workforce and the need to ensure a balanced and resilient workforce across the necessary specialisms. It takes considerable time and investment to produce the highly specialised nurses required to deliver the care the community expects and deserves.
The pandemic has shown that (despite assurances of surge capacity and systems resilience), nursing workforce issues remain central to our national response to COVID. Even while government assures us that hospitals stand ready to provide the care required, and that nurses from non-ICU areas are being rapidly upskilled to provide ICU care, some of our most influential nursing organisations raise concerns about sustainability and workforce burnout and exhaustion.
The pandemic has provided a period of reflection on work-life balance, compensation and work conditions, work flexibility and career development opportunity. We are witnessing a global trend, referred to as ‘The Great Resignation’ or ‘The Big Quit’ where employers are seeing dramatic changes in workforce, and health is not immune. In fact, health is one of the industries with higher rates of staff turnover.
Individuals are reflecting on how well they are treated by their employers and re-evaluating their relationships with their employment. COVID-19 has made many question their career choices and options. There are many issues at play including: workplace health and safety; mental health, stress, burnout and exhaustion; pay and conditions; and attractive work options, such as remote working. New roles have been created in the health workforce, such as contact tracers, coordinating mass vaccination hubs, and COVID screening centres creating new work options and career opportunities.
Due to the increased demand on specific specialties created by the pandemic, some roles will be more at risk of burnout and exhaustion such as critical care, emergency and mental health services. This burnout may contribute to individuals exploring potentially less stressful or less labour intensive work with better pay and conditions.
Many specialities face workforce concerns. The challenging findings of the final report of the Royal Commission into Aged Care Quality and Safety have identified a critical need for the registered nurse role in the aged care setting. The Health Department's 2020 Aged Care Workforce Census has further identified workforce shortages and challenges with attrition.
While nurses continue to deliver services to the community, this is often done at the expense of nurses’ wellbeing with reports of nurses working excessive hours caring for excessive numbers of patients. The Australian Nursing and Midwifery Federation has been conducting a campaign for legislated nurse-patient ratios – the ‘No more than four’ campaign. All of these factors highlight workforce shortages in crucial areas.
Debate and discussion on the staff composition and number of the nursing workforce is not a new item of dialogue. There have been assertions that we have more of a distribution problem, with greater shortages in rural and remote areas rather than an absolute shortage of nurses. Across the world, models for nurse workforce planning have not accounted sufficiently for social, political and economic factors as well as contextual nuances within the profession that can influence projections.
Moreover, narrow public perceptions of the role of nurses has influenced projections of fit within a contemporary job market.
Nursing is a valuable degree for a range of professional roles and nurses find themselves engaged in a range of sectors because of their knowledge, skills and competencies. Marvin Krislov wrote in Forbes Magazine that many professions could learn a lot from nursing particularly in respect of integrity, advocacy and empathy. It is still common to see nursing viewed as more of a vocation than a career choice, and attrition from the formal health sector as a failure rather than a measure of the value and transferability of skills obtained through a nursing degree. Of note degrees in law, business and medicine provide multiple career options and nursing should be considered as a similar option providing lifelong opportunities.
There is much discussion and debate on what the post-COVID era will look like. In common with other assaults on society, we are living in a period of reflection, recalibration and course correction because of the pandemic is occurring. COVID-19 has emphasised the importance of social determinants of health in determining access to services as well as the complex and multifaceted role of nurses across the care continuum. The deleterious forces of racism, alienation, inequity and marginalisation have also been apparent through this pandemic.
As nursing in Australia matures, evolves and assesses the impact of the pandemic we need to consider workforce planning in a new light.
Firstly, we need to address representation of all cultural groups and increase the participation of men.
Secondly, there is an urgent need to increase the numbers of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders in the workforce.
Thirdly, we should address public perception and misconceptions of our profession.
And lastly, we need to focus on the immediate priority of retention of the current workforce. We need to ensure we create and nurture ‘workplaces of choice’, fostering purpose and contribution, where kindness and wellbeing are central to the environments we work in, supported by attractive working conditions.
Ensuring we have robust nursing workforce forecasting in both the long and short term is critical. For too long planning has been reactive and not considered broader social, political and economic factors as well as the push and pull factors of migration. As our society faces a post pandemic world, which is ageing, health disparities are becoming more evident and the burden of chronic illness is increasing, ensuring we have adequately educated nurses in sufficient numbers is of the greatest importance.
Our current experiences certainly do not feel like we are living through a surplus, rather a crisis considering a critical discussion of distribution, competencies, skills and support.
Ignoring these issues is at the peril of not just today, but for populations of the future.
Professor Patricia Davidson is vice-chancellor and president, University of Wollongong.
Professor Debra Jackson is professor of nursing at the Susan Wakil Sydney Nursing School, University of Sydney.
Associate professor Caleb Ferguson is associate professor of nursing, Western Sydney University & Western Sydney Local Health District.

4 Comments
Karen Booth
Excellent article. Thank you. I agree, if there is NO nursing workforce shortage, why are state health depts desperate to bring in overseas trained nurses. Why are the jobs pages full of positions for RNs, EENs and other care workers? Primary health care and the bush are all desperate to employ more trained nurses. How are our new grads being supported? Older nurses are keeping the workforce afloat and significant numbers will look to retirement within the next 5 years. We need HELP!!