Skip to content Skip to sidebar Skip to footer

Nursing union case against state govt ‘last resort’ to address understaffing

The NSW nurses and midwives union says its legal action against the state government…

The NSW nurses and midwives union says its legal action against the state government was a 'last resort' to address allegations of widespread understaffing and mistreatment in public hospitals.

Last week, dozens of nurses gathered in front of Gosford Hospital after the NSW Nurses and Midwives' Association (NSWNMA) lodged a court case against the state government for breaching patient care awards.

The union alleges over 500,000 missed nursing care hours had occurred between December 2018 and October 2022, with most care hours missed in major state hospitals like Gosford.

The claim is based on data from a Government Information Public Access (GIPA) application that revealed 'statewide systemic non-compliance with staffing ratios' in hospitals.

NSWNMA general secretary Shaye Candish said suing the state government was the union's 'last resort' in demanding compliance after 'years of long-standing disputes with hospitals.'

"We need a circuit-breaker," Candish told Nursing Review.

"It's become common practice in some places for nurses to turn up short-staffed.

"We need to demonstrate to the government that this system is not working."

The NSW nursing union has been calling for safe nurse-to-patient ratios for the last decade, Candish said.

In late March, nurses and midwives from Wagga Wagga Base Hospital rallied to push for minimum and enforceable staffing ratios.

Most NSW hospitals use the Public Health System Nurses' and Midwives' (State) Award (NHPPD) to roster staff on a shift-to-shift basis, depending on the number of patients and their care needs.

But Candish said the staffing system is severely outdated and needs urgent change to stop more nurses from leaving the sector.

"The system is so broken, and nurses and midwives don't want to be part of it anymore," Candish said.

"Particularly in the last five years, we've seen a deterioration of the numbers of staff that are afforded daily on every shift."

Candish said a significant issue in the system is that it looks at the average over a 24-hour period and over a week, without taking into account a nurse's opinion on the day itself.

"We need an accountable, transparent and modern system," she said.

"There is no way we can have over 500,000 hours of non-compliance while working with a system that's functioning properly."

Last November, the NSWMA filed an application under the Freedom of Information act to receive state health department data on employment conditions breaches.

Candish said the information uncovered more than 500,000 nursing hours that were 'not being provided for', equating to roughly $18m in taxpayer dollars.

It also counted 10,000 separate breaches of terms and conditions of employment.

There were nearly 1,500 contraventions across ten state hospitals.

The NSWNMA implicated Central Coast's Gosford Hospital as one of the major sites, accounting for 777 award violations between 2018 and 2022.

Other breaches cited included 155 at Royal Prince Alfred Hospital in Camperdown and 107 at Concord Repatriation Hospital.

Candish said the contraventions filed with the court are a conservative estimate.

"With some of these facilities, we've been in long-standing disputes about the staffing," she said.

"Gosford, in particular, is one of the hospitals we've been very concerned about compliance with the required staffing arrangements.

"It means that the quality of care nurses can provide has been diminished."

In 2021-22, the state department said it lost nearly 13 per cent of its nursing staff, compared to 7 per cent in the previous three years, due to unsafe patient-to-nurse ratios and long working hours.

Candish said NSWNMA members also opt to work across the state border for better employment conditions.

She's seen nurses in border towns, such as the Gold Coast and Albury-Wodonga, now travel to Victoria or Queensland.

"We repeatedly hear from members that they would rather take a short drive to work across the border if it means they can work in a system with better ratios," Candish said.

"A better system in NSW will be critical for us to retain our current workforce because we're absolutely losing them."

During the prosecution case, the NSWNMA will argue leading hospitals will have missed out on almost 120,000 hours of nursing care due to ongoing understaffing.

The union has never before prosecuted the NSW government, and Candish said it was 'certainly not a decision taken lightly.'

She said she hoped it would lead to an improved staffing model that would bring nurses and midwives back into the NSW system.

"We need to get to a point where this stops, and there's recognition that this system is not working."

The NSW health department responded to the NSWNMA's prosecution case by saying the system was a 'flexible ratio' that allowed local health districts to determine whether increased hours were needed.

"We acknowledge there have been high numbers of furloughed staff due to Covid, industrial action, and planned staffing not aligning with subsequent demand," an NSW health department spokesperson said.

"Covid and the flu have had a particularly significant impact with thousands of NSW Health staff unavailable every day."

The health department continued that local health districts regularly report to the health ministry on the staffing system's compliance, which is 'reviewed at a local and state level.'

"Compliance is improving due to a combination of extensive and ongoing recruitment.

"There's been a record intake of new nursing and midwifery graduates in 2023, workforce strategies and the decreased impact of Covid."

Last week, Health Minister Brad Hazzard called the NSWNMA action' 'purely political', claiming the shifts made up for 1,500 nursing hours rather than 1,587,000 shifts.

"In my view, the union action will not get a lot of substance in court trying to get action ten days out from an election," Hazzard said.

"It is the ultimate hypocrisy by the union, using union members' money to run a campaign for a Labor party they know is not going to deliver them ratios."

If the court case rules in NSWNMA's favour, the Supreme Court could rule financial penalties for the state government.

Leave a comment