In August, the government introduced a radical new bill to tackle the nation's rental crisis, crack down on shonky immigration pathways, and direct more international students to our universities rather than private vocational providers.
The Minister for Education Jason Clare said that under the new reforms international enrollments into 2025 will be capped at 270,000 (this applies to higher education courses and vocational education and training courses) and universities will be able to determine their specific cap based on a formula designed to even the playing field.
"For some universities, some big universities, it will be lower than it was last year. For some of the smaller universities, some of the universities that have been hit hard by Ministerial Direction 107 [which slowed down processing of international education applications], it will be higher next year than it is this year," Mr Clare said.
Universities, businesses and tourism groups have since expressed their lack of support for the new scheme, and after a third bill hearing, the Senate said the legislation is still not ready to pass.
Recently, concern has grown amongst the universities that educate large cohorts of equity groups and skills shortage workers that the international student cap will undermine the Australian University Accord's mission; to make the higher education system better, fairer and more equitable.
Fewer nurses
The Australian Catholic University (ACU) is the largest educator of teachers and nurses in the country. Its pro-vice-chancellor of global and education pathways Christopher Riley said a cap on the number of international enrolments will have an impact on the uni's ability to continue to plug skills shortages in those areas.
International student fees are a considerable source of revenue for universities, most of which have said a financial loss from enrolling fewer overseas students compared to recent years will have an impact on the quality of domestic education.
ACU's indicative cap number for 2025 is over 55 per cent less than its 2024 international commencing enrolments.
"Our cap is 1700. Our commencing enrolment this year was 3770. Our enrolment in 2019 was 2212," Mr Riley said.
"Currently, we are still modelling the specific financial impact, but I can say that it will be profound.
"Additionally, the caps potentially diminish ACU's capacity to deliver groundbreaking research, to invest in teaching and our equity programs, and to deliver a world-class health and education workforce. The latter is particularly important given that we face crippling skill shortages in areas such as nursing."
Western Sydney University vice-chancellor George Williams – who has been especially critical of the legislation – said he was surprised the cap formula did not take into account available student accomodation numbers.
It is understood that universities will be allowed to renegotiate cap numbers if they invest in more purpose-built student accommodation to combat tight private rental markets in cities.
Although, Student Accommodation Council chief executive Torie Brown recently said, the logistics of how a cap renegotiation would work has not been clarified.
"I was, frankly, shocked when I read the letter. In fact, I read it twice, thinking I had missed some key content in the letter," Professor Williams told the Senate.
"The formula did not account for the most basic and important issues that we thought might be accounted.
"In our case – as a university that has a bed for every single international student, and, like ACU, trains nurses, who are desperately needed and whom the government is prioritising for Western Sydney – we can see the big impact on the community.
"We've got 20 per cent capacity in our housing. In fact, we were looking at building 500 new beds over the next couple of years but, again, that is one of the perverse outcomes. We're asking ourselves if we should build those beds because maybe we won't get the students to fill them."
He said the financial loss from the cap for his university will mean the institution will no longer be able to offer some of the vital programs domestic students need.
"The bottom line for us is that we're down a thousand students on the number of students we would have liked to take next year. That will cost us $26.5m in revenue next year, or about $78.4m across the life cycle of those students," Professor Williams continued.
"In our case, for every dollar we take in from an international student, 24 cents goes to supporting other activities, particularly our domestic students. So 24 cents in every dollar goes to our food pantry for domestic students, to equity issues and to study help."
Last year, WSU enrolled 1350 international students who studied nursing, most of whom went on to work in the NSW health system, particularly in Western Sydney.
"We are looking to expand that program over the coming years, or at least we were, and that's because there's a shortage of about 10,000 nurses in Western Sydney alone," the professor said.
"One of the consequences of this is that we'll have fewer nurses in our hospitals, particularly in Western Sydney, and some of the health problems we're facing in Western Sydney will be made worse. It would be different if domestic students were making up those numbers, but they're not."

Perverse consequences
He also repeated what has become common argument against the cap, that the formula used to calculate university's individual numbers is flawed.
"The results are somewhat arbitrary depending upon the years chosen – what happens in 2024 as opposed to 2023," he said.
"It's also clear that the results are somewhat random depending upon how people are affected by different aspects of the formula.
"I'd also like to say that there'll be a number of perverse and, I suspect, unintended consequences of the formula that again will negate some of the positive public policy intent behind it."
One of those perverse consequences will be that universities will most likely prioritise multiyear degree applicants over single-year degree applicants.
"The impact will be that we will be less likely to take the best and brightest students who want to study postgraduate research or other forms of postgraduate degrees, in favour of multiyear undergraduate degrees," he said.
"That also has a significant impact on the public policy intent, which is to control the number of people in Australia at any one point. In fact, because multiyear degrees will be favoured over single-year degrees, we will see, in outer years, a significant increase over the number of students that we would otherwise have taken without a cap.
"We'll also see a big impact on diversification. In our case, we'll be looking particularly to markets that can pay higher fees. We don't have any cohort above 20 per cent at our university. That's where we should be. But we'll be forced to specialise in markets and actually move away from what is a highly diversified portfolio."
Professor Williams called on the government to engage in deeper conversations with the sector.
"The bottom line for us is that we have the housing. We would have loved to have had a conversation about this to say: 'We are happy to open our books. We can show you the capacity in our housing,'" he said.
"None of our students need to go to the private market. Home-stay is another major option. We've got a letter and a number, and we'd say: 'Where is the national interest in imposing that outcome in light of our circumstances?'"
Overall, the higher education sector is concerned about the limit the cap puts on future financial planning.
"At the fundamental level, we don't plan for one year; we plan over multiple years. We plan a mix of international and domestic students and a mix of disciplines," UTS vice-chancellor Andrew Parfitt said.
"International students are a really important part of our IT, technology and engineering disciplines, areas of significant skills shortage.
"Our initial planning to recover from Covid-19 and recover from deficits has been impacted by a number that's probably a thousand students fewer than we would have planned for next year – $40m – and that pipelines into multiple years with no clarity around how any growth might come through the system."
