Skip to content Skip to sidebar Skip to footer

Public takeover of Northern Beaches Hospital hailed as major milestone

Just 18 months after the death of two-year-old Joe Massa, the government has taken ‘unprecedented’ action

The mother of a young boy who died after a series of errors took place at Northern Beaches Hospital (NBH) has praised the NSW government for its “unprecedented” action in taking over the hospital.

Initially opened as a public-private partnership (PPP) in 2018, the hospital will officially transition to full public ownership under NSW Health on Wednesday. The change comes after a series of government probes found serious administrative and financial shortfalls were causing significant errors to occur, resulting in an inability for the hospital to adequately care for patients.

The most glaring instance came in September 2024, when two-year-old Joe Massa died because of a critical misdiagnosis.

Staff initially believed the boy was suffering from gastroenteritis due to a reported bout of vomiting, and neglected to rediagnose him after his mother Elouise noticed his heartbeat was rising rapidly.

It was eventually found that Joe was suffering from hypovolemia – a severe lack of fluids – resulting in his death from cardiac arrest shortly after his parents brought him into the emergency ward.

Danny and Elouise Massa successfully lobbied for a ban on private-public partnerships at acute care NSW public hospitals in March last year. Picture: NCA NewsWire/Nikki Short.

Speaking to NewsWire, Ms Massa said the change to the hospital was “one of the very last pieces of the puzzle” which she and Joe’s father, Danny, had been tirelessly advocating for since their son died.

“For me, as a local mum, knowing that our emergency department will now be in state hands means that if you have an imminently life-threatening condition, then you have a far greater chance of survival now than you would have had in 2024,” Ms Massa said.

“I was told that I was asking for too much and that I should be careful, but I knew that what I was doing was right … to work proactively and collaboratively with the government was so important and I’m so grateful for their collaboration and their partnership on this,” she said.

“It’s a huge milestone.”

In the aftermath of her son’s death, Ms Massa advocated strongly for an overhaul in early intervention processes so that they place a higher level of importance on the intuition and knowledge of parents and family members of patients admitted into hospitals.

Established in late March by NSW Health, the Raise It program established an urgent care helpline that parents and families can access if they feel like their loved one needs an immediate reassessment from hospital staff.

“It doesn’t matter what state-run hospital you’re in New South Wales, you will have a senior clinician on the other line answering your call immediately, and they will escalate your concerns,” Ms Massa said.

“This information will save lives.”

NSW Health Minister Ryan Park has spearheaded the reformation of Northern Beaches Hospital. Picture: NCA NewsWire/John Appleyard.

NSW Health Minister Ryan Park said wrestling ownership back over the hospital, which has included a near-total transition of staff from Healthscope to NSW Health, had been “an enormously challenging piece of work”.

“It’s important that while we transition the hospital over that nothing slips through the cracks … This is probably one of the single biggest reforms this government has undertaken,” Mr Park said.

“We’re doing this at a fast-forward pace so it’s beyond challenging, but we want to get the transition right … I’m not going to pretend there’s not going to be bumps along the way. That would be foolish. This is a challenging piece of work and it involves a live hospital – we aren’t dealing with static assets like road transfer or anything like that,” he said.

Mr Park said the staff at NBHl had dealt with “a pretty difficult set of circumstances” but that 96 per cent of those who received job offers from NSW Health had taken them.

“When your hospital is in the spotlight every other day, it becomes quite challenging, and one of the reasons we’ve been moving so quickly is because we needed to stabilise the workforce and provide certainty to the community,” Mr Park said.

“We’ve done that very pleasingly.”

NSW Nurses and Midwives’ Association general secretary Michael Whaites said the transition was “a long time coming” for members, who had repeatedly raised concerns about staffing and safety under the public‑private partnership.

“We are relieved that this milestone has finally arrived, after raising staffing and safety concerns at Northern Beaches Hospital for years,” Mr Whaites said.

He said the union began fighting the privatisation 13 years ago, warning the former Coalition government that the PPP model “would be detrimental to the people of the Northern Beaches.”

While the union successfully defeated privatisation plans for Bowral, Wyong, Goulburn, Maitland and Shellharbour hospitals, the one for NBH had proceeded.

“There is overwhelming evidence that PPPs are not the right model for delivering public healthcare services to the community, and we are extremely pleased to see another failed PPP transferred to public ownership,” he said.

NSWNMA assistant general secretary Katrina Bough credited staff for their persistence.

“Nurses and midwives working at Northern Beaches Hospital have fought long and hard for this win, advocating for safe patient care and quality health services every step of the way. They never gave up the fight to have the hospital taken out of private hands,” she said.

Leave a comment