Skip to content Skip to sidebar Skip to footer

Fears monkeypox stigmatising LGBTQI+ communities seeking healthcare

The monkeypox outbreak that has been recognised as affecting mainly men who have sex…

The monkeypox outbreak that has been recognised as affecting mainly men who have sex with men has raised concerns over possible stigmatisation of the gay community when accessing healthcare.

Since the virus' numbers began to rise in May, there have been 31,400 reported cases in 80 countries.

Most of the people infected involved men who identified as gay and bisexual, which was underlined by a survey in June that found that of over 500 people with monkeypox, 98 per cent were gay or bisexual men.

Heath Paynter, the acting CEO of Australia's peak community-controlled HIV organisation AFAO, worries stigmatisation around the virus may impact members of the gay community seeking health services.

"There's tension between framing monkeypox as a gay disease, which it's not because anyone can get it," he says.

"But we know that the virus is transmitted mainly through interconnected sexual networks among gay and bisexual men.

"So, at the moment, there's hardly a risk to heterosexual people – the risk is for gay and bisexual men if they're going to have sex with men."

Since the WHO announced monkeypox as a global threat, public health officials have had to balance their decision-making between reaching out to high-risk groups without potentially stigmatising its community members.

In a 28 July news briefing, WHO director-general Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus said that the outbreak can be stopped if the government takes appropriate measures and individuals protect themselves from the virus. 

He called for "men who have sex with men to reduce their number of sexual partners, to reconsider sex with new partners, and exchange contact details with any new partners to enable follow-up if needed".

But Heath says we must prioritise the provision of safe and acceptable healthcare for the LGBTIQ+ community.

Individuals from the gay community report having negative experiences when seeking health services.

People don't always have an understanding of the particular needs of those with diverse sexual orientations or gender identities, Heath says.

"Oftentimes, they experience stigmatising and judgemental attitudes from health service providers.

"And, of course, this jeopardises their confidence in the system and drives them away from healthcare."

Heath emphasises the gay community is more likely to experience poorer health outcomes when using mainstream services.

"All the while, they're actually a community in need of higher levels of healthcare," he says.

Australian-led studies have brought to light that gay and bisexual men use healthcare more frequently but are often less satisfied with the service they receive.

One major survey, Private Lives 3, revealed that just over half of those in the LGBTIQ+ community felt their sexual orientation or gender identity was respected by people in the health sector.

Only 54 per cent of gay people and 43 per cent of bisexual-identifying participants felt accepted 'a lot or always' when accessing health or support services.

The survey also found that three-quarters of the respondents preferred healthcare providers who were accredited as LGBTIQ+ inclusive.

Heath says it highlights an increased need for appropriate health services for a community still facing stigma.

"It's essential that we provide community-controlled LGBTIQ health services.

"But we also need to have a conversation with gay and bisexual men in language that is familiar, sensitive, and non-stigmatising.

"If we can manage to have that talk – free from judgement and stigmatised language – we can strengthen the confidence of gay and bisexual men accessing our health system." 

Heath emphasises that those talks need to be led by community leaders and organisations that are trusted by gay and bisexual men.

"Australia has achieved highly at having sensitive conversations with gay and bisexual men through its history, and through the community responsive history of HIV," he says.

"So I'm confident that we can again achieve highly in containing monkeypox if we strengthen their confidence in our system and offer the opportunity for people to get the vaccine."

LGBTQ health organisations have been pushing for the government to roll out a monkeypox vaccine program while the government has slowly responded to rising case numbers.

Australia is following in the footsteps of New York and England, who already started to provide vaccines to protect gay and bisexual men in June.

Last Monday, NSW made available 5,500 monkeypox vaccines to curb the state's rapidly climbing cases.

Health Minister Mark Butler also announced they secured another 450,000 doses of new third-generation vaccines, with the first delivery of 22,000 to arriveby the end of this year.

Yet, Heath says demand is likely to outstrip supply as he expects those from the gay and bisexual community won't hesitate to line up for the vaccination.

"They will want to protect themselves and get the vaccine," he says.

Associate Professor Meru Sheel from the University of Sydney says that while figures show infections are more common in gay and bisexual men, members from that group are also more likely to come forward for testing.

"We know from other diseases that these populations present more for testing, so we're detecting more cases in them as well," she says.

"So of all these global reported cases, it doesn't necessarily mean all infections are detected. 

"That's only the ones who are presented or have been diagnosed."

Meru is an infectious diseases epidemiologist specialising in public health emergencies and immunisation.

She calls for a strong health response to ensure we prevent the virus from spreading further.

"We need to communicate and educate the population for prevention," she says.

"There's a risk that if the disease keeps spreading the way it is, it will circulate within the gay and bisexual population more."

She says that, similar to when HIV came into view, the virus started within gay populations who had sex with men but then spread into other groups. 

"We must work closely with communities and key advocacy groups to ensure that we are relaying the information in a meaningful way.

"Because all outbreaks start and end in communities."

Background into monkeypox

Monkeypox virus was discovered in 1958 when two outbreaks occurred in groups of monkeys kept for research, and the first human case was recorded in 1970.

The virus is closely related to the family that causes smallpox, but while symptoms are similar, those of smallpox are often more severe.

Still, those infected with monkeypox often develop extremely painful skin lesions which can take weeks to clear.

"It's the same family of the variola virus that causes smallpox," Meru says.

"It belongs to this family of orthopoxviruses, which are these double-stranded DNA viruses.

"That means they're more stable than RNA viruses, such as SARS-CoV2, so they're not going to go through constant mutations."

She says that because smallpox was eradicated in 1980, the population has not been vaccinated and may be more susceptible to the monkeypox virus.

"Population immunity might be declining because of the cessation of smallpox vaccination programmes and increase in urbanisation," Meru says.

"There may also be a mutation in the virus that is leading to the rapid spread of the virus.

"But the reason is still unclear. What we do know is that travel and high-risk activities are essentially leading to the massive spread."

Like Covid-19, monkeypox is a zoonotic virus that originated in mammals and eventually jumped to humans.

Experts say that deforestation, urbanisation and climate change may be the root cause of the rise of zoonotic viruses.

"People now are more frequently coming into contact with animals which leads to a higher chance of virus transition," Meru says. 

"I think we've learned a lot through Covid.

"So, it's vital to work towards containing the disease as much as possible and quickly."

Leave a comment