National peak body for nurses, the Australian College of Nursing (ACN), has released a position statement proposing that all school-aged children in Australia have access to a registered nurse that is suitably qualified to provide guidance on maintaining a healthy weight.
However, many eating disorder experts have expressed concerns that subjecting children to in-school weight management will cause more harm than good.
Butterfly Foundation chief Dr Jim Hungerford said he has seen obesity measures like these backfire before.
“Butterfly frequently hears from our lived experience community that health promotion and strategies that take a weight-centric approach do not result in “reduced stigma” – it reinforces it," he said.
"Preventative health policy must align with eating disorder prevention, and we must broaden our definition of health to beyond a weight-centric, diet culture lens.”
The Australian College of Nursing (ACN) believes that nurses are uniquely positioned to identify at-risk children and hopes that in providing this service, the nation will begin to normalise the collection and discussion of height and weight data for all children.
As of 2022, over a quarter (28 per cent) of all Australian children aged between five and 17 were classified overweight or obese, based on Body Mass Index (BMI) measurements. In 1995, the proportion of children who were overweight was around 20 per cent, growing to 25 per cent by 2017-18.
“Nurse-led interventions, which are proven effective in various settings, offer a flexible and cost-effective solution,” ACN's Emeritus Professor Leanne Boyd said.
“Supporting nurses with training, resources, and leadership opportunities is crucial to optimise impact in combating childhood obesity.
“ACN supports policies that ensure every school-aged child has access to a qualified nurse.
“We recommend reforms to prioritise nurse-led care models."
These recommendations include the utilisation of healthcare funding to prioritise nurse-led models of care for areas that intersect nurses and children, the introduction of longitudinal mapping of children's height and weight on growth charts and providing professional development opportunities for nurses to learn to "identify children at risk and provide timely, sensitive interventions targeting a whole-family approach to improve eating and activity behaviours."
The Eating Disorders Alliance (EDA) encompasses the major eating disorder organisations in Australia and New Zealand, including the Butterfly Foundation and Eating Disorders Families Australia, and has said that ACN's recommendations will only "exacerbate weight stigma, encourage disordered eating and foster body dissatisfaction."
Research has found that anorexia nervosa is the deadliest of all mental disorders in Australia and one of the most costly to the public health system too. In 2023, eating disorders represented the third highest burden of disease among young females, only behind anxiety and depressive disorders.
Furthermore, according to a study released this year by Deloitte Access Economics, the cases of eating disorders among Australians aged 10 to 19 are growing. Currently, children and adolescents make up 27 per cent of all eating disorder cases. This statistic has nearly doubled since 2012.
Belinda Chelius, CEO of Eating Disorders Queensland, highlighted that even the term ‘healthy weight’ is based on outdated and problematic measurements of the human body – Body Mass Index (BMI).
“Placing emphasis on weight control/reduction in health messaging has been shown to promote disordered eating behaviours, reduce physical activity, and discourage health behaviours," Ms Chelius said.
“Over 340 references to Body Mass Index (BMI), weight, calories, healthier, class surveys, food and diet were removed or replaced from the Australian Curriculum in November 2023. It is disappointing to see a step backwards recommended," adds Eating Disorders Families Australia director Jane Rowan.

Researchers from Monash University recently teamed up with The Obesity Collective to release a new academic paper addressing the untapped potential of healthcare professionals to reduce weight stigma.
Lead author Dr Briony Hill, deputy head of Monash University's Social Care Unit, School of Public Health and Preventive Medicine, said the perpetuation of weight-based shame by health professionals is extremely harmful to patient wellbeing.
“While we know that most healthcare professionals do not intend to cause harm, they may be harbouring negative attitudes and biases towards their larger-bodied patients, potentially impacting the care they provide," Dr Hill said.
“To reduce and ultimately end weight stigma in healthcare, approaches supporting both individual clinicians and the health system more broadly are needed. Healthcare professional training should focus on clear and practical guidelines that support them to ‘do no harm’, improve their practice, and recognise and address their own biases.
“Structural measures to eliminate weight stigma must address the physical environment, develop policies that support weight stigma reduction, and foster transdisciplinary action to optimise patient and health system solutions.”
ACN has cited an Obesity Collective report, published earlier this year, as the foundation of their recommendations. The EDA has invited ACN to revisit their position statement to "ensure a safer, more inclusive approach to health and wellbeing that is informed by lived experience and does not focus on weight."
