Skip to content Skip to sidebar Skip to footer

When midwives face their own birth trauma: study

A groundbreaking study is investigating the 'overlooked issue' of midwives coping with their own…

A groundbreaking study is investigating the 'overlooked issue' of midwives coping with their own birthing trauma and its impact on their professional lives. 

It's estimated that one in three women who deliver a baby experience some level of trauma.

But according to PhD candidate at Southern Cross University and registered midwife Lisa Charmer there's a significant gap in research on how this impacts a midwife returning to the workforce.

"Many midwives may not realise they've been affected until they re-enter the workplace and are confronted by their experiences," Ms Charmer said.

"They may find it emotionally challenging, leading them to eventually leave or decide not to return to the workforce at all."

The study is interviewing practising midwives to better understand their experience of a personal birth trauma, also called primary trauma, and how it affects them returning to the maternity workplace.

Ms Charmer said that while childbirth is typically seen as a positive experience, complications and adverse events can increase the risk of post-traumatic stress symptoms (PTSD).

PTSD is a mental health condition that can develop in people who have experienced or witnessed a traumatic event.

While the event has passed, people are left with intense feelings and disturbing thoughts that can lead to heightened anxiety and fear, depression and detachment.

People with PTSD may 'relive the traumatic event' through flashbacks and nightmares and can avoid or respond negatively to situations that remind them of those events.

Ms Charmer emphasised that reaching the stage of PTSD is the 'worst-case scenario' and that many midwives experience individual symptoms or effects.

"Knowing the significant impact of secondary trauma on a person, we can only presume there may also be implications when it’s personal birth trauma," she said.

"There is acknowledgement of the impact of secondary trauma on midwives working with women who have less than an ideal birth.

"However, when her own baby’s birth is traumatic, very little is known about the impact on midwives’ general health and mental wellbeing as well as on her professional quality of life."

Ms Charmer said the lack of research into primary trauma was 'surprising' considering over 88 per cent of the workforce is female, and many have 'walked their own birthing journey.'

"It's extra complicated because midwives have such unique professional knowledge about childbirth as well."

Witnessing traumatic events can have a profound emotional impact on people and lead to the loss of self-confidence at a personal and professional level.

For midwives experiencing traumatic births can be particularly challenging since they're often emotionally connected with these events.

A study conducted in the Netherlands found that 13 per cent of midwives were traumatised after witnessing a problematic birth. 

Another study reported that over 35 per cent of American midwives experienced PTSD due to traumatising childbirth.

Most midwives faced PTSD and avoided similar events after witnessing neonatal deaths and miscarriages.

Ms Charmer said the research underlines the significant impact of traumatic births on midwives, either primary or secondary, and provides them with psychological support to cope effectively.

"I've found that some midwives have had positive experiences with supportive managers who facilitate a gradual transition back to work," Ms Charmer said.

"But there are also instances where midwives have not been as fortunate in receiving such support.

"Overall, there are no specific initiatives or programs available to midwives in Australia, as far as I'm aware."

Ms Charmer said that she decided to research the topic after experiencing the difficult births of her three children.

"When I returned to work, I reflected on those experiences and decided to do this study," she said.

"The ultimate goal is to provide much-needed support for midwives as they navigate their return to the workplace.

"Better support could also help address the retention of midwives in the workforce."

Ms Charmer is looking for more midwives to participate in the survey. 

Leave a comment