Emergency nurses are experiencing a hidden form of psychological harm that researchers say is contributing to burnout, workforce shortages and challenges in patient care.
Recently released research led by Murdoch University lecturer and PhD candidate Clare Walters has highlighted the impact of ‘moral distress’ on emergency department (ED) nurses, describing it as the emotional burden that occurs when nurses know the right course of action for a patient but are unable to deliver it because of institutional or system barriers.
The scoping review, published in the Journal of Clinical Nursing, examined a decade of international research into moral distress among nurses in the ED.
“I’ve been that nurse. I’ve stood in overcrowded emergency departments trying to provide safe, compassionate care, while managing too many patients with too few resources,” Ms Walters said.
“Those experiences stay with you. They don’t just end when the shift finishes.”
The review found moral distress is consistently linked to emotional exhaustion, reduced professional satisfaction, increased intentions to leave the profession and perceived compromises to patient care.
“Moral distress has been recognised as a critical issue in nursing ethics, with research identifying its association with burnout, psychological distress, disengagement and attrition from the profession,” the authors wrote.
Researchers identified recurring causes including overcrowding, understaffing, resource shortages, organisational constraints, perceived futility of care and the depersonalisation of patients in busy emergency settings.
According to the review, emergency nurses represent a particularly vulnerable group because they regularly work in environments characterised by unpredictability, high patient acuity, limited resources and rapidly changing priorities.
The paper notes that emergency nurses must often balance competing priorities under significant time pressure while managing multiple patients simultaneously, frequently with limited information.
The World Health Organization has estimated a global nursing shortfall of 4.1 million nurses by 2030 and has warned that significant investment will be required to educate and retain the workforce.
Australia is already feeling the effects of workforce shortages, with the review citing evidence that more than 300 emergency nursing positions are advertised on any given day.
Related: Violence against nurses surges | Support sessions ease midwife burnout | Only two-thirds of patients treated on time in Australian EDs
Ms Walters said the profession needed to move beyond placing responsibility for coping solely on individual nurses.
“If we want to retain experienced emergency nurses, we need to stop thinking of resilience as an individual responsibility,” she said.
“We cannot keep asking nurses to become more resilient, while simultaneously expecting them to work in systems that repeatedly place them in ethically impossible situations.”
Researchers identified a lack of evaluated interventions, organisational strategies and leadership approaches specifically designed for emergency nursing environments.
The authors argue that moral distress is largely driven by system-level factors and that organisational responses should extend beyond wellbeing programs and resilience training.
They recommend a stronger focus on safe staffing levels, appropriate skill mix, support for graduate and early-career nurses, clear escalation pathways, supportive mentorship and leadership practices that encourage staff to raise ethical concerns.
“Leaders who promote open communication without reprisals and respond transparently to concerns may help validate nurses' moral agency and mitigate distress,” the review said.
Ms Walters said the consequences of moral distress extend beyond nurses themselves.
“This is not just about nurse wellbeing. It is about the patients waiting hours to be seen, only to be put in a corridor bed with no privacy,” she said.
“It’s about creating a healthcare system where nurses can provide the care they came into the profession to give.”
